send your notes on error corrections and additional references
on this topic
to the Webmaster (Marie Kroun) at LymeRICK - http://LymeRICK.net
Note: PDF-files must be viewed using Adobe Reader, is a free download from: www.adobe.com
More references on
persistence of and seronegative Lyme borreliosis can
be found at:
|Lymeinfo (all PDFs):||Relapse/Persistence
67 refs. in upd. 2003*)
might differ in newer
|Seronegativity in Lyme borreliosis and Other Spirochetal Infections (17 pages, 103 refs, upd. 2003*)|
|Cystic form of Borrelia burgdorferi: an introduction (17 pages, 2003*)|
|Cystic Form of Bb & Other Spirochetes: Advanced (30 pages (4Mb, many pictures), 73 refs., upd. 2003*)|
|Cystic Forms of Spirochetes: A Complete Bibliography, 1905-Present (49 pages, 254 refs, upd. 2005*)|
|Symptoms (51 pages, 2006* – p44: 19 fatality reports, p47-49: detection of Borrelia)|
|Symptoms Supplement (8 pages, 2003*)|
The list of references described below is far from a complete literature overview; the list consist only of articles reviewed by the editor in full text.
The original text was written in MS-Word
back in 2001-2003,
which unfortunately gave problems when opening
the page(s) in other browsers than Internet Explorer. The
unfortunately chosen to use
the PubMed UI number for linking to
PubMed decided to discard using UI and only
so in order to make all the links to PubMed
abstracts work again, all the references had to be changed
from UI to PMID, which was
done in 2003. In order to ensure same layout in different browsers, the
editor had to learn HTML-coding according to the W3-HTML
4 rules/standards, and how to take advantage of
easier layouting with a common LymeRICK Cascading
sheet (CSS), this was done in 2007.
The editor also added / corrected some broken links to available free download PDFs; those links may not work always, however, because publishers may decide to change their free download policy and/ or their website / linking method, or their server may be down.
references have been added since 2003, because the editor has
simply not had the time/energy to do an extensive literature search.
Most important newer references added are on reports on "NEW" BORRELIA STRAINS - B. lusitaniae and B. valaisiana - that were detected in material from HUMAN patients with a disease history compatible with CHRONIC ACTIVE BORRELIOSIS, that were SERONEGATIVE despite very long-term illness duration (10 years).
Thus over the past 10-20 years, more and
more ANTIGEN VERIFIED EVIDENCE has piled up, supporting the
view of ILADS
CHRONIC (=long term duration) (seronegative) ACTIVE
(=symptomatic) BORRELIOSIS (despite previously given
antibiotic therapy) is a possibility, that we have
to consider, in those CLINICALLY SUSPECTED BORRELIOSIS CASES,
that do not recover fully after an usual short course of antibiotic
Since most of the published BORRELIA ANTIGEN VERIFIED CASES below showed beneficial effect of re-treatment with antibiotics - at least as long as the treatment is being continued - on patients with ANTIGEN VERIFIED persistent / recurring symptoms of borreliosis, and there are few reports on severe adverse effects of antibiotic treatment! - and the fact that serology tests failed to be positive in many ANTIGEN proven cases of Borreliosis (up to about 50%, one could flip a coin instead of wasting money on those serology tests!)
- all this EVIDENCE taken into account, indicates clearly, that patients with persistent / recurrent symptoms consistent with possible chronic borreliosis after treatment, should be investigated meticulously with ANTIGEN tests, because it is very important to get certain proof of the tentative clinical diagnosis if possible, not only for Borrelia (all strains possible including the "new"), but also for potential co-infections, that may cause alteration in disease expression, and in response to antibiotic treatment and in host immune function; clinically suspect borreliosis cases should be offered trial antibiotic treatment no matter the results of tests, and IF positive response to antibiotic, this must be seen as yet another positive sign, supporting the clinical diagnosis of infection.
ABSCENCE OF PROOF FOR INFECTION, IS NOT PROOF FOR ABSCENCE OF INFECTION!
A diagnosis of chronic borreliosis can not be made from positive, nor can it be excluded from negative test results solely!
Borreliosis is mainly a CLINICAL DIAGNOSIS, that must be based on a disease history with:
1. suspected/known EXPOSURE to tick/Borrelia/other TBI (previously recognized tickbite, previous erythema migrans, previous or current positive serology are all positive indicators of exposure to Borrelia plus eventual other tickborne infections simultaneously)
2. CURRENT SYMPTOMATOLOGY especially when in a characteristic cyclical pattern (prospectively registered / described in a very detailed symptom log (Excel diary) and might be
3. supported by positive test results, and last but not least, the
4. RESPONSE TO ANTIBIOTIC TREATMENT (followed from day to day with the diary, during treatment, compared to before treatment, will measure and document both beneficial as well as adverse effect of antibiotic treatment!)
- are all factors that must be taken into consideration by the patient and doctor, when establishing diagnosis and decide on treatment!
The editor needs YOUR HELP to maintain the functionality of all links and information on this page, so PLEASE NOTIFY the LymeRICK webmaster, in case you discover any broken links or any other errors in any of the LymeRICK texts and you are of course very wellcome to suggest further scientific articles to be added to LymeRICK reference lists on selected topics!
TOP European American Animal
Cultivation of Borrelia
joint fluid three months after treatment of facial palsy due to Lyme
Schmidli J, Hunziker T, Moesli P, Schaad UB. J Infect Dis 1988 Oct; 158(4): 905-6 PMID: 3171237
15.5y girl. Tickbite Oct. 1986. No EM. No 'flu'. Jan. 1987 left facial palsy. Positive Bb serology. Amoxicillin-clavulanate 625mg x4, 12d discontinued due to rash. Betamethasone 1mgx2, 2 weeks. Lumbar puncture, normal CSF. Oral doxycycline 100mgx2, 14d, facial palsy resolved. Two months later arthritis in the right knee. Cloudy joint fluid 60ml,positive culture for Bb. Ceftriaxone 4g/d, 3g - 2g/d, 11d.
in the spleen of a patient with chronic Lyme disease.
Cimmino MA, Azzolini A, Tobia F, Pesce CM. Am J Clin Pathol 1989 Jan; 91(1): 95-7 PMID: 2910019
A 54-year-old man had intermittent evening fever, arthralgia, transient erythematous macular eruption on the skin, and splenomegaly of two year's duration. Immunofluorescence tests for Borrelia burgdorferi serum antibodies gave positive results, but G-penicillin treatment was ineffective. Splenectomy with lymph node biopsy was performed to rule out lymphoproliferative disorders. Borrelia-like spirochetes were identified histologically in the spleen; this finding was consistent with persistence of B. burgdorferi organisms in inner organs in chronic Lyme disease.
Lyme neuroborreliosis: presence of Borrelia burgdorferi in the
cerebrospinal fluid without concurrent inflammatory signs.
Pfister HW, Preac Mursic V, Wilske B, Einhaupl KM, Weinberger K. Neurology 1989 Aug; 39(8): 1118-20 PMID: 2668788
Male, 20 tickbites Aug-Dec while jogging in forest
.. Dec 87 bilat.
weeks was the ONLY
IgG seropositive for anti-Bb (1:64) with normal IgM titers (indicates 'late'), indicated lumbar puncture. Bb could be cultured from CSF, without any concurrent signs of inflammation or intrathecal antibodyformation. CSF: 1 WBC/µl and 21 mg/dl protein.
Neither oligoclonal IgG bands ...... nor intrathecal production of specific antibodies against B. burgdorferi could be demonstrated .... The CSF/serum ratio for antibodies against B. burgdorferi (RBb) was 0,28% .... Three months later .... Repeated lumbar puncture revealed 2 white cells/µl and 23 mg/dl protein without demonstration of oligoclonal IgG bands or intrathecal production of antibodies against B burgdorferi.
The only symptom - tinnitus - didn't respond to usual antibiotic treatment(?), so authors conclude this symptom was unrelated to Bb.
Would this young man - months or years later - have developed symptoms of neuroborreliosis?
of Borrelia burgdorferi in antibiotically treated patients with
Preac Mursic V, Weber K, Pfister HW, Wilske B, Gross B, Baumann A, Prokop J. Infection 1989 Nov-Dec; 17(6): 355-9 PMID: 2613324
1. 5y boy. July 1985 EM. Aug 1985 Lymphocytic meningitis. Seropositive for IgG and IgM, no antibodies in CSF. Penicillin V orally 100000 u/kg/d, 14d. Spinal-fluid showed fewer cells. September 1985 facial palsy, again pleocytosis in CSF. Doxyc. orally 2mg/kg, 10d. Gradually CFS normalized. April 1986 relapse, Bb was isolated from CSF after 4 weeks in BSK-medium. Penicillin 200000 u/kg, 22d. August 1986 relapse/reinfection with EM and painful meningoradiculitis, Bb antibodies now negative in CFS and serum. Culture not done!
2. 49y man. EM, typical signs of LMR-Bannwarth S developed 7 weeks later. Pleocytosis and elevated protein in CSF. Both Borrelia IgM and IgG positive in serum. Penicillin i.v. 20 MU/d, 10d. Four days after therapy normal examination and no complaints, CSF declining parameters, positive Borrelia-index. Three months later CSF normal, Borrelia-index now negative, but Bb was cultured from CSF!
3. 26y woman. Headache, radicular pain. Normal neurological exam. Multiple horseflie bites. CSF pleocytosis and elevated protein. Negative Borrelia-ELISA in CSF and serum. Ceftriaxone i.v. 2g/d , 10d. Improved. 7.5 month later recurrent episodes of radicular pain, headache, arthralgia, fever. Normal neurological exam. Negative serology. Normal CSF. Bb cultured from CFS after 6 weeks in MKP-medium. Cefotaxime 3 x 2g/d i.v., 14d.
4. 44y man. EM june 88, no other complaints. Seropositive. Bb isolated from skin biopsy from border of EM. Phenoxymethylpenicillin 1 MU x3/d, 12d. Three months later normalized serology, but Bb was again isolated from skin biopsy adjacent to the scar of the first biopsy. No other manifestations of Borreliosis. Ceftriaxone 2g, 21d. Later skin-culture negative.
5. 40y man. EM, fatigue, headache. Penicillin G 10 MUx1, 10d, starting 5 weeks after the tick bite. Serum Borrelia IgG and IgM negative. Two months after treatment headache and fatique, low Borrelia-titre positive. At bite area, but no sign of EM, was culture positive for Bb, 2.2 mo. after treatment.
6. 60y woman. Oct. 87 EM 32x20 cm of duration 6 months. Methylprednisolone 4 mg daily for asthma for years. Sep. 87 she had doxycycline 200 mg daily, 10d, by family physician for cold. Palpitations, dizziness, but had had angina pectoris for years. IgM and IgG against Bb negative. Bb was isolated from edge of EM oct 20, 87. Pt. refused to take more antibiotic.
comparison of ceftriaxone and cefotaxime in
Pfister HW, Preac Mursic V, Wilske B, Schielke E, Sorgel F, Einhaupl KM. J Infect Dis 1991 Feb; 163(2): 311-8 PMID: 1988514
In this prospective, randomized, open trial, 33 patients with Lyme neuroborreliosis were assigned to a 10-day treatment with either ceftriaxone, 2 g intravenously (iv) every 24 h (n = 17), or cefotaxime, 2 g iv every 8 h (n = 16). Of the 33 patients, 30 were eligible for analysis of therapeutic efficacy. Neurologic symptoms improved or even subsided in 14 patients of the cefotaxime group and in 12 patients of the ceftriaxone group during the treatment period. At follow-up examinations after a mean of 8.1 months, 17 of 27 patients examined were clinically asymptomatic [i.e 10/27 = 37% were symptomatic]. In one patient Borrelia burgdorferi was isolated from the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) 7.5 months after ceftriaxone therapy. CSF antibiotic concentrations were above the MIC 90 level for B. burgdorferi in nearly all patients examined. Patients with Lyme neuroborreliosis may benefit from a 10-day treatment with ceftriaxone or cefotaxime. However, as 10 patients were symptomatic at follow-up and borreliae persisted in the CSF of one patient, a prolongation of therapy may be necessary.
of Borrelia burgdorferi in the cerebrospinal fluid of 3
children with neurological involvement]
Peter O, Bretz AG, Zenhausern R, Roten H, Roulet E. Schweiz Med Wochenschr 1993 Jan 13; 123(1-2): 14-9 PMID: 8421774
Isolation of Borrelia burgdorferi from the CSF is relatively rare. The present report describes the first three isolations in Switzerland. Clinically, our first observation confirmed the frequent association of B. burgdorferi with peripheral facial paresis in children. The other two cases illustrate the variety of symptoms in neuro-borreliosis.
1. In the first case the culture was positive after 6 weeks. The results of serologic tests (indirect immunofluorescence and ELISA) for detection of antibodies against B. burgdorferi were negative or non-significant in this child's serum. On the other hand, specific antibodies (IgG) were detected in the serum by western blot.
2. Culture of the second CSF already showed Borrelia growth after 10 days. Immunofluorescence revealed high antibody titers (1/256) against B. burgdorferi in this patient's serum. IgG showed a weakly positive reaction in western blot. The reliability of this result was confirmed by isolation of Borrelia.
In neither of the two CSF could intrathecal synthesis of specific antibodies be demonstrated.
3. In the third case, however, immunofluorescence showed IgG antibody titers of 1/128 in the CSF and 1/512 in serum. Intrathecal synthesis of specific antibodies was demonstrated with an index of 13.4 (norm < 2). Western blot confirmed the specificity of the reactions observed with the serum and CSF IgG. Culture of CSF produced significant growth of Borrelia within 7 days. Protein profile and reactions with poly- and monoclonal antibodies confirmed that the three strains belonged to B. burgdorferi. (ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
encephalitis caused by concomitant infection with tick-borne
encephalitis virus and Borrelia burgdorferi.
Oksi J, Viljanen MK, Kalimo H, Peltonen R, Marttia R, Salomaa P, Nikoskelainen J, Budka H, Halonen P. Clin Infect Dis 1993 Mar; 16(3): 392-6 PMID: 8452951
We describe a 38-year-old farmer from the southwestern archipelago of Finland where both tick-borne encephalitis (TBE) virus and Borrelia burgdorferi are endemic. He presented with fever and headache, developed severe meningoencephalitis in 3 days, and, after 1 month, died without regaining consciousness. High titers of IgG and IgM antibodies to TBE virus were present in both serum and CSF. Serology for Borrelia was negative. Autopsy revealed necrotizing encephalitis and myelitis with involvement of the dorsal root ganglion. With use of polymerase chain reaction tests, segments of two separate genes of B. burgdorferi were amplified from the patient's CSF. This case demonstrates that the possibility of dual infection should be considered for patients residing in geographic areas where Ixodes ticks may carry both the TBE virus and B. burgdorferi. We believe that the most severe damage in this case was caused by TBE virus rather than by B. burgdorferi. Nevertheless, the coinfection might have contributed to the fatal outcome that has not been previously observed in Finnish patients with TBE.
initially treated with penicillin plus gentamicin, next day changed to
cefotaxime, later erythromycin was added ... plus dexamethasone. All
discontinued when TBE virus infection was confirmed. Later highly
febrile from pneumonia (40oC), imipenem,
rifampicin and vancomycin and amphotericin B.
Imipenem-sensitive E.coli was isolated from the trachea. Later
difficile was isolated from a stool sample obtained while the patient
diarhea. .... Died.]
"With use of ELISA, significantly raised antibodies to sonicated whole B. burgdorferi and to purified endoflagellar antigen were not detected in either serum or CSF (table 1). A CSF specimen for polymerase chain reaction (PCR) was taken." ....."With use of the PCR method, a B. burgdorferi-specific segment of a gene coding for 41-kD endoflagellin  and a Borrelia-specific segment of 16S rDNA  were amplified from the CSF (table 1).
isolation of Borrelia burgdorferi from an iris
Preac Mursic V, Pfister HW, Spiegel H, Burk R, Wilske B, Reinhardt S, Bohmer R. J Clin Neuroophthalmol 1993 Sep; 13(3): 155-61; discussion 162 PMID: 8106639
The persistence of Borrelia burgdorferi in six patients is described. Borrelia burgdorferi has been cultivated from iris biopsy, skin biopsy, and cerebrospinal fluid also after antibiotic therapy for Lyme borreliosis. Lyme Serology: IgG antibodies to B. burgdorferi were positive, IgM negative in four patients; in two patients both IgM and IgG were negative. Antibiotic therapy may abrogate the antibody response to the infection as shown by our results. Patients may have subclinical or clinical disease without diagnostic antibody titers. Persistence of B. burgdorferi cannot be excluded when the serum is negative for antibodies against it.
6 cases with persistent culture positive Bb, isolated from 1) iris, 2)
3-6) 4 x CSF,
1) pos. iris culture despite previous tx doxy 200mg/dg 4 weeks. x 2, seropositive;
2) EM +culture, tx doxy 200mg/dg 10 days. Seronegative. 1 yr iritis, not responsive to steroid, but to ceftriaxon.
3) Weak seropos. CSF normal, neg. index, but culturepos. CSF
4) Weak seropos. CSF normal, neg. index, but culturepos. CSF
5) tickbite, penicillin orally x 2 for 12 days. 4 month later CSF elev. prot. 6/3 cells, seronegative + CSF-seronegative, but CSF culturepos. for Bb.
6) Weak seropositive in serum, CSF negative, Bb was cultured from CSF.
of Borrelia burgdorferi in ligamentous
tissue from a patient with chronic Lyme borreliosis.
Haupl T, Hahn G, Rittig M, Krause A, Schoerner C, Schonherr U, Kalden JR, Burmester GR. Arthritis Rheum 1993 Nov; 36(11): 1621-6 PMID: 8240439
The patient, a 48-year old woman, presented with progressive disturbance of the central vision in her right eye. Ophthalmoscopy demonstrated multifocal choroiditis, with 1 focus involving the macula lutea. The patient reported that 2 months previously, a tick had bitten her left lower leg, near the ankle, and she had experienced occipital headaches and a macular skin lesion. Serologic tests performed at our university revealed a positive IgG antibody titer against B burgdorferi. Other infectious diseases, particularly toxoplasmosis, were excluded by laboratory evaluations. The patient was treated with 200 mg/day of doxycycline (orally) for 6 weeks (Figure 1). The visual disturbance was ameliorated, the inflammatory foci of the choroid diminished, and scar tissue formed.
Four weeks after the end of antibiotic therapy, the patient began to experience brief episodes of an asymmetric arthritis, primarily involving the metacarpophalangeal (MCP) and proximal interphalangeal joints. Routine electrocardiography (EKG) revealed negative P waves, with an ectopic atrial pacemaker that had not been present on an EKG performed at gall bladder surgery 1 year previously. On ophthalmoscopic examination of the eye fundus, there was no evidence of a recurrence of the choroiditis.
Tests for antinuclear antibodies, immune complexes (by Clq binding assay and polyethylene glycol precipitation), rheumatoid factor (RF), immunoglobulins, serum complement levels, and C-reactive protein levels all gave normal or negative results. HLA phenotyping revealed HLA-A24/26:B7/27;Bw4/6;Cw2/7;DRl5(DR2 split);DQ1. Despite the presence of the HLA-B27 antigen, there was no evidence of any typical manifestation of a seronegative spondylarthropathy.
Therapy was started with 2 grams of ceftriaxone, intravenously, for 14 days (Figure 1). Within the next 4 weeks, the ectopic atrial rhythm converted to a normal sinus rhythm, and the arthritis disappeared. After 2 months free of clinical symptoms, the visual disturbances recurred. Ophthalmoscopy showed reactivation of the initial foci of choroiditis. Analysis of CSF demonstrated normal levels of albumin and IgG, no disturbance of the blood-CSF barrier, negative findings on immunofluorescence (IF) analysis for B burgdorferi-specific antibodies, and a normal cell count; thus, there was no evidence of an inflammatory process involving the central nervous system.
Antibiotic therapy with a combination of 300 mg of roxithromycin, 1,600 mg of sulfamethoxazole, and 320 mg of trimethoprim per day, which has been described as effective in several cases of advanced Lyme borreliosis (6,7), was initiated. However, tenosynovitis and mild arthralgia of the patient's hands occurred. Despite concurrent antibiotic therapy, "trigger thumb" developed within 2 weeks, accompanied by pronounced pain of the MCP joint, and surgical splitting of the flexor retinaculum was performed (Figure 1).
After exsanguination of the patient's right arm, surgery was performed in a bloodless field. The macroscopic appearance was typical of "trigger finger." A specimen of the altered ligament was obtained, with particular attention to avoiding surface contamination of the tissue sample. The specimen was rinsed several times in saline and medium, and was placed in culture with modified BSK medium. The patient's postoperative course was without complications, and normal functioning of the operated thumb was achieved. Six weeks after the course of antibiotics, the choroid foci were scarring. Unfortunately, the patient had an irreversible, 70% reduction of vision in the right eye. Approximately 3 weeks later, the arthralgia also disappeared. Currently, after approximately 2 ½ years of followup, there has been no evidence of reactivation of the Lyme borreliosis.
Immunofluorescence assay and findings. The IF assay was performed as described earlier, using the German isolate of B burgdorferi, PKo 2-85 (3,8). Serum samples were preabsorbed with Treponema phagedenis lyophilysate (Behringwerke, Marburg, Germany. For the detection of specific IgM antibodies, a second absorption step with RE absorbent (Behringwerke) was performed. Using this technique, titers in control sera were <1:16. In parallel, the serum samples were analyzed using a commercial B burgdorferi enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) kit (Viramed, Munich, Germany, with a protein preparation of B31 Borrelia,, as antigen. A positive, a negative, and a borderline control specimen served as internal standards. The ratio between the optical density of the serum samples versus that of the borderline specimen was used to quantitate the results. Ratios >1.0 were considered positive; those <1.0 were negative.
IF analysis revealed positive titers of IgG, but not IgM, antibody directed against B burgdorferi only during the early stage of infection when the patient presented with the first episode of choroiditis. Analysis by ELISA revealed comparable results, with specific IgG ratios of 1.15 at the onset of disease and 0.85 in the later stage. The IgG titer rapidly decreased within a few weeks after the first antibiotic therapy, and remained negative in both the IF and ELISA evaluations, despite progression of the disease.
Immunoblot analysis and findings. For immunoblot analysis, we used a method previously described (9), in which lysed specimens of whole B burgdorferi strain PKo 2-85 and LW2, the isolate from the patient (see below) (protein concentration 100 µg/ml), were separated by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (5 µg of protein per lane) in a 10% gel. Proteins were transferred to nitrocellulose and incubated with the sera at a dilution of 1:100, which we had previously found yielded optimum results. Bound immunoglobulins were visualized by application of peroxidase-conjugated reagents. Polyclonal antisera from patients with Lyme disease and monoclonal antibodies against outer surface protein A (OspA) and flagellin (the latter kindly provided by M. D. Kramer, Institute of Immunology and Serology, University of Heidelberg, Germany) were used to compare the isolated spirochete LW2 and the B burgdorferi strain PKo 2-85 by immunoblot.
All serum samples from the patient were tested against protein preparations of both the LW2 and the PKo 2-85 strain, on immunoblots. There were no significant differences in reactivity to the isolates. Upon repeated analysis of several consecutive serum samples, only nonspecific faint bands (75 kd, 41 kd, and 15 kd) were revealed, demonstrating a pattern different from that found in typical patients with stage III disease (10).
Preparation of mononuclear cells and results of lymphocyte proliferation assay. Peripheral blood mononuclear cell (PBMC) separation and antigen stimulation were performed as described previously (8.9) Freshly isolated cells (105/well) were stimulated in triplicate with either 105 or 106 PKo 2-85 B burgdorferi per well, 10 µg/ml of recombinant OspA, 10 µg/ml recombinant flagellin (41-kd protein) from B burgdorferi (both expressed and purified as described elsewhere ), or 7 µg/well of T phagedenis lyophilysate. Previous studies had shown these to be optimal concentrations (8,9). Control wells received either medium alone or tetanus toxoid (10 µg/ml; Behringwerke). Samples from normal blood donors were run in each assay to exclude any nonspecific response. It has been clearly documented by appropriate separation experiments (9) that reactivity to Borrelia antigens under these conditions is T cell derived.
Stimulation of the patient's PBMC with the 2 strains of B burgdorferi as well as with OspA resulted in significantly elevated 3H-thymidine uptake at all times tested (compared with normal PBMC) (Figure 1). Tetanus toxoid induced high levels of 3H-thymidine uptake, between 143,000 and 181,000 Dcounts per minute (stimulation values in the presence of antigen minus those in the absence of antigen). In the earlier disease stages and prior to ceftriaxone therapy, proliferation to Borrelia antigens corresponded well to the clinical course, despite negative findings on IF and ELISA testing, reaching peak values at peak disease activity, as manifested by intermittent arthritis and cardiac involvement (Figure 1). After the ceftriaxone therapy and a 2-month symptom-free period, PBMC proliferation decreased, but during a period of minor inflammatory reactivation of the disease, was still elevated. The patient's symptoms at that time were choroiditis, mild arthralgia, and the development of "trigger finger." B. burgdorferi was isolated from ligament samples.
Isolation and characterization of B burgdorferi strain LW2. Tissue samples from the flexor retinaculum of the patient's right thumb were taken during surgery for the "trigger finger." Samples were cultured at 37°C under microaerophilic conditions, in modified BSK medium. Cultures were evaluated weekly for spirochetes in the supernatant, as detected by darkfield microscopy. After 3 weeks, viable spirochetes were seen. This particular spirochete, designated LW2, was used as antigen for immunoblot. B burgdorferi-specific immune sera and monoclonal antibodies against OspA and flagellin stained protein bands in a pattern comparable to that of the PKo 2-85 bacterial antigen (data not shown). An aliquot of this supernatant was examined for B burgdorferi-specific gene sequences by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification and Southern blot.
PCR and Southern blot techniques. Cultured spirochetes from the patient's tissue specimen were investigated by standard PCR procedures (11). We used primers which amplified a 276-basepair segment (kb-ladder; Gibco BRL Life Technologies. Munich, Germany) of the 41-kd flagellin protein of B burgdorferi (primer 5'-TTCAGGGTCTCAAGCGTCTTGGACT-3'; reverse primer 5'-GCATTTTCAATTTTAGCAAGTGATG-3') (12,13). The amplification protocol consisted of 40 cycles: 1-minute denaturation at 940C, 30-second annealing at 500C, and -minute extension at 670C.
An amplification product, which could be hybridized by Southern blot technique with the 32P-g-ATP-labeled probe 5'-CTCTGGTGAGGGAGCTCAAACTGCTCAGGCTGCACCGGTTCAAGAGGGT-3' (13) using Hybond-N nylon-blotting membranes (Amersham, Amersham, UK), was obtained. The amplimer, which was characterized by Picken (13), is derived from the central, nonhomologous region of the flagellin gene. It has been shown to be both specific for B burgdorferi and discriminatory for 3 groups of this spirochete, based on the nucleic acid sequence. Water, synovial tissue from a patient with rheumatoid arthritis, and B burgdorferi strain PKo 2-85 were used as negative and positive controls for the studies.
Electron microscopy techniques and results. Transmission electron microscopy was performed on the ligament tissues. The specimen was removed from the culture medium and prepared and analyzed as described previously (14). Semithin sections were cut from the plastic block for the light microscopic evaluation. Thin sections were cut from selected areas and placed onto copper grids (Polysciences, St. Goar, Germany). After counterstaining with 10% uranyl acetate, followed by 2.8% lead citrate (both from Merck, Darmstadt, Germany), sections were studied using Siemens EM 101 (Munich, Germany) and Zeiss EM 902 (Wetzlar, Germany) electron microscopes.
The ligament tissue was found to be heavily infiltrated by spirochetes. Some of the organisms lay between unaltered collagen fibers (Figure 2A); others were closely attached to the cell surface of the fibroblasts (Figure 2B). There were numerous fibroblasts deeply invaginated by the spirochetes, thereby creating membrane-bound cavities. These cavities appeared as vacuoles in transverse tissue sections.
The patient whose case is presented herein had relapsing Lyme borreliosis, with choroiditis, arthritis, carditis, and tendinitis. The humoral immune response correlated with neither the cellular reactivity in vitro nor the clinical activity of the disease manifestations. Repeated antibiotic treatment was necessary to stop the progression of disease, but obviously did not completely eliminate B burgdorferi from all sites of infection. This was confirmed by the culture of viable B burgdorferi from a ligament sample obtained surgically. This organism characterized by molecular biology studies by our group, was subsequently evaluated in a genomic comparison study of other isolates. In that study, Wallich et al identified the genogroup AAA (flagellin type at, heat shock protein [HSP] 60 type A, and HSP 70 type A), and OspA genotype I (15). Electron microscopy of the ligament revealed spirochetes situated between collagen fibers or associated with fibroblasts, deeply invaginating these cells. This is the first time that B burgdorferi was isolated from human ligamentous material.
These data indicate that vital B burgdorferi persisted (a) despite several courses of antibiotic therapy, (b) even when clinical symptoms subsided, and (c) even when no humoral immune response was detectable by ELISA or by IF. Therefore. the hypothesis may be raised that an inadequate immune response as well as an evasion into immunologically privileged sites may be the mechanisms of microbial persistence in patients with chronic Lyme borreliosis.
The specific humoral and cellular immune responses to B burgdorferi, which were elevated during early disease manifestations, apparently were not sufficient to eliminate the pathogen. In the later stage, these specific immune responses became discordant, with negative humoral and positive cellular immunity, as has been described in another cohort with chronic disease (16) [Dattwyler RJ et al. Seronegative Lyme disease: dissociation of specific T- and B-lymphocyte response to Borrelia burgdorferi, NEJM 1988; 319:1441-46].
Interestingly, the cellular immune responses were also directed against the surface protein OspA during each recurrence of clinical symptoms, even though anti-OspA antibodies were not detectable by immunoblot. Interpretation of this dissociation of the humoral and cellular immune responses is difficult and requires further investigation. Initial experiments with T cell clones in patients with chronic Lyme disease (17) [Yssel H et al. Borrelia burgdorferi activates a T helper type 1-like T cell subset in Lyme arthritis. J Exp Med 1991 Sep 1; 174(3): 593-601] suggest that selective activation of a T cell subset may occur, producing a restricted pattern of cytokines which are incompetent to activate B cells.
Even in the presence of an ineffective immune response, antibiotic therapy should have eradicated the spirochetes and stopped the disease progression in our patient. However, several of the treatment regimens recommended in the then-current literature, including combination therapies which have been described as effective in several refractory cases of advanced-stage disease (6,7), did not eliminate the pathogen. Of interest, our patient showed the DR15 (split of DR2) HLA type (possibly even homozygous), which has been shown to be associated with a poor response to antibiotic therapy in chronic B burgdorferi infection (4) [Steere Ac et al, Association of chronic Lyme arthritis with HLA-DR4 and HLA-DR2 alleles, NEJM 1990; 323:219-23]. Possible explanations for the persistence of Borrelia are that spirochetes either develop resistance to the antibiotics (though not experimentally documented so far) or escape into sites at which drug levels are ineffective. The detection of spirochetes between collagen fibers of bradytrophic dense connective tissue supports the second hypothesis. Moreover, the motility of spirochetes has been shown to be enhanced in fluids as viscous as the extracellular matrix (18) [Kimsey RB et al Motility of Lyme disease spirochetes in fluids as viscous as the extracellular matrix. JID 1990; 162: 1205-8]. The hypothesis of evasion supports the use of more aggressive therapy as described in recent reports (19), in which 3-4 weeks of intravenous antibiotics was suggested as first-line treatment when systemic manifestations develop, such as the choroiditis in our patient.
Although our electron microscopic studies were of a subcultured ligament specimen, and therefore in vitro effects cannot be excluded, it is of great interest that spirochetes penetrated into the extracellular matrix without causing apparent destruction. Spirochetes had also deeply invaginated into fibroblasts, thereby suggesting transcellular passage. Penetration of cell monolayers by B burgdorferi has been demonstrated (20) [Comstock LE et al: Penetration of endothelial cell monolayers by Borrelia burgdorferi. Infect Immun 1989; 57:1626-28]. In conclusion, an inappropriate immune response as well as the evasion of B burgdorferi into specific sites that are only slightly accessible to antibiotics and immunologic attack, may be mechanisms that lead to chronic infection with B burgdorferi.
Addition: Intracellular location protect Bb from antibiotics that do not cross cell-membranes ex. penicillin, cephalosporin [Georgilis K et al. Fibroblasts protect the Lyme disease spirochete, Borrelia burgdorferi, from ceftriaxone in vitro. J Infect Dis 1992 Aug; 166(2): 440-4]
microscopy and the polymerase chain reaction of spirochetes
from the blood of patients with Lyme disease.
Hulinska D, Krausova M, Janovska D, Rohacova H, Hancil J, Mailer H. Cent Eur J Public Health 1993 Dec; 1(2): 81-5 PMID: 8004045
95 patients, only 3/30 attempts were culture positive, but by Immune electron microscopy (IEM) 9 of 30 blood samples demonstrated borreliae. The decisive diagnostic method was:
positive had EM, 21 could be classified as early Lyme borreliosis with
neurological symptoms, 6 as late stage Lyme borreliosis
14 had antibodies only in blood, 6 both in blood and CSF, the remaining 10 non-reactive by 2 different tests.
blood culture positive patient had prior history of EM followed by
meningoradiculitis and positive IgM and IgG in serum the second [with
culture] had facial palsy with complaints of headache, weakness and
pain in the
arms that lasted 8 days, while the serology being negative.
The other (third) with positive culture had a long history of Lyme borreliosis with arthralgias and complaints fulfilling the criteria for neuroborreliosis. He had an erythema and often removed ticks from his dog. During his illness he had all symptoms of Lyme borreliosis and also positive serology. He was in good condition after having taken antibiotics for 3 months before the blood culture was done.
One patient with positive IEM and subsequent (positive) culture went through all phases of Lyme borreliosis and two years of persisting complaints! … after repeated treatment [drug? dose? duration?]
"Our culture of spirochetes from the patient with meningoradiculitis followed after skin Erythema migrans confirmed the presence of B. garinii, identified by PCR, which caused the neurological disorder - even in the presence of antibodies and antibiotic treatment. One patient remained symptomatic for a period for two years after repeated treatment, but B. burgdorferi was cultured when the patient was relatively well."
with Lyme [see comments]
Vartiovaara I. Lancet 1995 Apr 1; 345(8953): 842-4 PMID: 7605437
- a physician, psychiatrist, who at the time was editor of the Finnish
Journal, tells his own story - a must read for all physicians, since he
describes not only the technical details of his disease, but also about
difficult the situation is, when a physician becomes a patient.
He contracted Lyme disease when attending a meeting in Vancouver, where he got bitten by a tick in bed at night and three weeks later he was sick.
A history of antibiotic-responsive Lyme borreliosis, but relapsing when treatment was discontinued.Seronegative.
PCR positive for borrelia in CFS+blood after three antibiotic treatments.
multiple-site osteomyelitis caused by
Oksi J, Mertsola J, Reunanen M, Marjamaki M, Viljanen MK. Clin Infect Dis 1994 Nov; 19(5): 891-6 PMID: 7893875
In a pediatric case of severe multiple-site osteomyelitis caused by Borrelia burgdorferi, the presence of spirochetes in a bone lesion was documented both by culture and by the polymerase chain reaction (PCR). Positive PCR results were also obtained with culture fluid yielding spirochetal growth and with acute-phase serum. Although the disease evidently was a late manifestation of Lyme borreliosis, antibodies to B. burgdorferi were low in titer and were restricted to the IgM class. The distribution of osteomyelitic lesions in multiple bones and the positive PCR results obtained with serum argue for hematogenous spread of the spirochetes. Before the specific diagnosis was established, the patient received several potent antimicrobial drugs, without a favorable outcome. In contrast, therapy with ceftriaxone led to a rapid cure that persisted thereafter. We conclude that infection due to B. burgdorferi must be considered a possible cause of subacute pediatric osteomyelitis.
against whole sonicated Borrelia burgdorferi spirochetes,
41-kilodalton flagellin, and P39 protein in patients with PCR- or
culture-proven late Lyme borreliosis.
Oksi J, Uksila J, Marjamaki M, Nikoskelainen J, Viljanen MK. J Clin Microbiol 1995 Sep; 33(9): 2260-4 PMID: 7494012 PDF
PCR or culture proven LATE Lyme Borreliosis of at least 3 months
had been sick for more than 6 months!
12 were culture positive, 39 PCR positive, 10 positive by both!
3 different serologic test were used / compared on all these ANTIGEN VERIFIED LATE BORRELIOSIS CASES - see more excerpts from this article here ...
kinetics of Borrelia burgdorferi and bacterial findings in relation
to the treatment of Lyme borreliosis.
Preac Mursic V, Marget W, Busch U, Pleterski Rigler D, Hagl S. Infection 1996 Jan-Feb; 24(1): 9-16 PMID: 8852456
[published erratum appears in Infection 1996 Mar-Apr;24(2):169] = "On page 12, because of technical reasons it was unfortunately not mentioned that information regarding Case I was provided by Dr. D. Hassler."]
In vitro investigation. Amoxicillin, doxycycline, cefotaxime, ceftriaxone, azithromycin and penicillin G. Killing effect investigated during a 72h exposure in MPK-medium and human serum with negative Lyme borreliosis serological tests.. Twenty clinical isolates were used ...
.. the results show that the kill kinetics of the borreliae differs from antibiotic to antibiotic. The killing rate of a given antibiotic for borreliae is less dependent on the concentration of the antibiotic than on the reaction time. Furthermore, the data show that the killing effect of isolates of B. garinii differs from that in B. afzelii species. Very interesting and unexpected is the different effect of antibiotics on isolates within one species. Also the different reaction of one strain to tested antibiotics is surprising.....
In summary, the result of killing kinetics suggest that:
Furthermore, the persistense of B. burgdorferi s.l. and clinical recurrences in patients despite seemingly adequate antibiotic treatment is described. The patients had clinical disease with or without diagnostic antibody titre to B. burgdorferi. Includes five case stories showing culture confirmed relapses after 12-14 days treatment courses.
Case 1: 51y man plexus neuritis. Positive serology for Borreliae IgG, WB. Cefotaxime 3x2g a day 12 days. Antibodies to Borreliae disapperead in months. Five years later a new attack with headache and pseudoradicular pain located in the region of the right arm plexus. Negative Bb and Western Blot. Half a year later progressive cardiac pain and dyspnoe on exertion. Angiography and echocardiography revealed 3rd degre mitral insufficiency. The patient had a history of 7 years of cardiomyopathy. Mitral valve replacement was carried out. Borreliae was cultured after prolonged incubation (9 weeks) from the excised mitral valve. Bb antibodies negative (ELISA, WB, IFT).
Case 2: 13y old boy with right gonarthritis. Positive IgG and IgM serology for Borrelia. Treated with ceftriaxone 2g/day for 14 days. Joint swelling diminished, but later recurred. Six months later synovectomy grew Borrelia afzelii from synovia as well as from the effusion.
Case 3: painfull knees, treated with corticosteroid. Lyme-IFGT-IgG borderline. Treated with ceftriaxone 2g/day for 14 days. Recurrent arthritis. About half a year later IgG in serum and and synovial fluid was positive. B. afzelii was isolated from the effusion.
man. One year history of headache,
eruption (lymphocytoma benignum) and arthralgia.
isolated from skin biopsy (B. garinii). Cefriaxone
2g/day 14 days.
The back pain diminished, other symptoms persisted. Doxycycline dose? 10 days.
Persistent arthralgias. Antibody titers against Bb s.l. negative, but Borreliae was isolated from a subsequent biopsy. Oral penicillin dose? for 14 days. The antibiotic treatment resulted in reduction of arthralgias [comment: but not symptom free, not cured?]
Case 5: 28y woman. Arthralgia multiple joints. Corticosteroids and doxycycline dose? duration?. After a 2-year history of pain and an increase in inflammation in the knee and hands synovectomy was performed. Borrelia IgM and IgG was negative, but nevertheless B. afzelii was isolated from hand synovia and the patient was treated with ceftriaxone.
brain changes in Lyme borreliosis. A
report on three patients and review of literature.
Oksi J, Kalimo H, Marttila RJ, Marjamaki M, Sonninen P, Nikoskelainen J, Viljanen MK. Brain 1996 Dec; 119 (Pt 6): 2143-54 PMID: 9010017
The patient was a 51-year old woman with a history of progressive lymphoedema of the left lower limb since 1954. She had suffered from erysipelas in the left lower leg and erythema nodosum in both legs, and had also had recurrent fever episodes several times a year. Lung fibrosis, heart insufficiency and chest pain atypical of coronary heart disease developed at the age of 30-35 years. She had received long-term corticosteroids and several courses of antimicrobial drugs.
patient had a 3 week period of fever and facial redness suggestive of
erythema. Despite corticosteriod treatment, a spiking fever persisted.
hospital, no infection focus was found. Antimalarial drugs, combined
methylprednisolone were given for two years, but episodes of mild fever
reappeared. Antinuclear antibodies and antibodies against extractable
were repeatedly negative. Anti-DNA-antibodies were found slightly
After september1988, she was hospitalized several times for prolonged vomiting, fatigue, fever, dizziness and progressive walking difficulties with ataxia and short gait. In addition, impairment of memory, taste, and hearing occurred. In february 1988, the erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR) was 125 mm/h serum C-reactive protein 83mg/ml (normal <10 mg/ml), and leucocytes 9.2 x 109 with 96% granulocytes. Sinus X-ray showed sinuitis, and the brain CT showed an empty sella. Despite treatment with methylprednisolone and i.v. erythromycin, the ESR and C-reactive protein remained elevated. At CSF examinations (February 1989 and January 1991), leucocyte counts and protein concentrations were normal, as was the IgG/albumin ratio, but one or two subfractions were observed with protein electrophoresis. In January 1991, MRI of the brain showed enlarged ventricles, cortical atrophy, and marked degenerative changes in the periventricular areas (Fig. 1A). Total serum immunoglobulins were normal, but immune electrophoresis showed an M-komponent (IgG lambda). Circulating immune complexes also occurred. Rheumatoid factor, antinuclear antibodies, anticardiolipin, TPHA (treponema pallidum haemagglutinations test), anti-phospholipid antibodies, and antibodies against B. burgdorferi were negative in serum. Leucocytes were 3.5 x 109 /l with an excess of band forms. In August 1991, CSF examination showed no inflammatory cells, a slightly elevated protein concentration of 762 mg/l, and no antibodies against B. burgdorferi. Culture of CSF in BSK-II medium showed very slow growth of spirochetes during 3 months. Using monoclonal antibodies, immunoflourescence and PCR, the spirochete was identified as B. burgdorferi s.l.
In December 1991, antimicrobial treatment with ceftriaxone (2g i.v. daily) was instituted. The patient improved slightly, and therapy was continued after 3 weeks with oral amoxicillin (500 mg every 8 h) and oral probenecid (500 mg every 8 h).
After 1 week on amoxicillin the patient developed urticaria. Oral doxycycline (100 mg every 12 h) was substituted and continued until July 1992. During this treatment, the walking difficulties and fever episodes recurred. All cultures for fungi and common bacteria were negative. In January 1992, brain MRI showed slight progression of the periventricular lesions from the image obtained 1 year earlier. In March and July 1992, subdural haemorrhages of unknown origin were evacuated.
On August 7, 1992, plasma and bone marrow specimens were positive for B. burgdorferi PCR. Treatment with ceftriaxone (2g i.v. daily) was reinstituted, the patient reacting with high fever. Empirical antifungal therapy with amphotericin B was also started. These treatments were continued until the patient died on September 12, 1992.
At autopsy, the pathological changes were slighter than expected. The spleen was slightly enlarged. Chronic liver stasis and mild pulmonary oedema were detected. No signs of fungal infection were seen. Neuropathological examination showed a chronic left-sided subdural haematoma. Its structure was compatible with the haemorrhages ocurring 6 and 12 months before death. An increased number of plasma cells were present within the organizing connective tissue of the haematoma. In subcortical and periventricular white matter, diffuse demyelination with mild perivascular inflammation was seen (Fig. 1B and C). In one of the six analysed brain tissue specimens, B. burgdorferi DNA was detected by the PCR.
This 40-year old man had previously been healthy, apart from reactivation of a genital herpes infection some weeks before. He recalled no tick bites or erythema migrans. On December 26, 1992, he had a generalized seizure and was admitted to the hospital. Another seizure ocurred on the day of admission. Brain CT was normal. On admission, CSF examination showed an unremarkable increase of protein level (688 mg/l) with no inflammatory cells. The PCR assays for herpes simlex virus (HSV) and antibodies against viruses were negative in the CSF. Serum IgM antibodies against B. burgdorferi were found at a low level and IgG antibodies against Chlamydia pneumoniae were moderately elevated. Serum C-reactive protein was 50 mg/l, lactic dehydrogenase 927 U7l (normal value <20 U/l), but the changes were transient. Other labororatory tests were normal including serum hepatitis B surface antigen, antibodies against HIV and herpes virus. The EEG showed an irrative focus in the left hemisphere.
On December 30, MRI of the brain showed three small frontal lesions at the bottom of the left frontal lobe near the meninges. The imaging of these lesions was enhanced using contrast medium (Fig. 3A). In the right pleural cavity, a chest X-ray examination showed fluid, which disappeared in 2 weeks. The CT showed a central cystic lesion n the left kidney, but no abnormal findings were obtained in the mediastinum, lungs, or pleural cavities. On December 31, a CSF examination showed 4 x 106 /l lymphocytes, but protein (373 mg/l), and angiotensin convertase enzyme and lysozyme concentrations were normal. The CSF antibodies against herpesviruses, B. burgdorferi, and Treponema pallidum were negative as was antigen for HSV and PCR for B. burgdorferi. The PCR for HSV was positive with this specimen. Culture for viruses and mycobacteria remained negative.
On January 8, 1993, a frontally located lesion was resected for suspected malignancy. Histopathological studies showed lymphocytes in the walls of leptomeningeeal and small penetrating arteries as well as in the perivascular space of the latter (Fig. 2B). The adjacent cortex was slightly oedematous with very mild astrocytic gliosis. A PCR analysis of three separate brain specimens detected DNA of B. burgdorferi. The IgM (but not IgG) antibodies against B. burgdorferi were positive only in the first pretreatment sample serum samples, but negative thereafter. The circulating immune complexes and complement activation products were positive. The IgG antibodies against C. pneumoniae were elevated at a constant level, but IgM antibodies remained negative, indicating that the IgG antibodies were of earlier origin. A neuropsychological investigation showed memory impairment affecting verbal function anf slightly impaired fluency of verbal expression. Anticonvulsive therapy with carbamazepine was started. Table two shows changes in the antimicrobial treatment schedule and the development of the brain lesions appearing on MRI. During the antibiotic treatment, MRI of the brain showed new lesions, one enhancing lesion (2 cm in diameter), suggestive of focal vasculitis, located medially from the post-operative area, and later, enhancing lesions at the bottom of the right frontal lobe and a frontal lobe sulcus (Fig. 3A and B). However, the initial lesion at the bottom of the lest frontal lobe behind the orbita was now markedly smaller than at previous examination. Later images showed that the first lesion was constantly reducing in size, and five months after onset of antibiotic therapy all the new foci of the putative vasculitic process had also disappeared. The antibiotic therapy was discontinued on July 5, 1993.
The patient was asymptomatic at the end of therapy. Whole body bone scanning was carried out in June 1993 because of a history of pain in the thoracic spine some months earlier. Slightly increased uptake of isotope in the thoracic spine was seen, but the finding was considered unspecific. The EEG after sleep deprivation was normal in July 1993.
Five months after the end of antibiotic therapy, brain MRI showed a new focus located adjacent to the third ventricle (Fig. 3 A and B). Oral antibiotic treatment was started (the patient was asymptomatic: see table 2). The next MRI showed that the treatment had probably had beneficial effect on the former lesions, but again, a new focus in frontal sulcus and a relatively large pathological area in periventricular white matter were detected (Fig. 3B). On May 17, 1994, DNA of B. burgdorferi was detected by PCR in the patients plasma specimen (Table 2). Intravenous antibiotic therapy was reinstituted and continued for 100 days. Thereafter, on MRI studies of the brain, all lesions and perivascular enhancement have disapperared, and no new lesions have developed to date (Table 2). The antiepileptic therapy has been discontinued, and no new seizures have occurred.
In the summer of 1993, this previously healthy 11-year-old girl had visited an area in Southern Finland where Lyme borreliosis is endemic. In September 1993, occasional episodes of hyperactivity followed by headache were observed by her family. On October 1, she developed paresis of the right lower limb. On October 7, she was admitted to a local hospital and 1 week later to the Oulu University Central Hospital. Standing on the right leg alone was difficult, and walking was slightly impaired. On October 13, CT of the brain showed a periventricular low density enhancing lesion. 10x6 mm2 in diameter, and located in the left parietal lobe white matter. The lesion was suggestive of a neoplasm. On the next day, using MRI, the dimensions of the enhancing lesion were found to be 40x20x8 mm3 and the surrounding oedematous area was 20-30 mm thick (fig. 4A). The EMG was normal. Abdominal ultrasonography showed mild splenomegaly. On October 22, a craniotomy was carried out. In the area of the enhancing lesion, shown by MRI, elastic and stretchy tissue with abnormal white colour was detected. On histological examination, focal necrotic areas were found, surrounded by foamy macrophages, reactive astrocytes and oedema. (Fig 4B). An increased number of small vessels with thickened walls and prominent endothelial cells were also seen. Lymphocytes occurred in the walls of some vessels.
Haemoglobin, ESR and serum C-reactive protein values were normal. Serum total immunoglobulins were normal, except for a slightly increased value of IgM at 1.94 g/l (normal value 0.35-1.63 g/l). Serum rheumatoid factor, antinuclear antibodies extractable nuclear antigens, anti-DNA and anti-phospholipid antibodies were negative, and so were antibodies against several viruses. On November 4, lumbar puncture was carried out. The CSF specimen gave a negative virus culture as HSV PCR, but B. burgdorferi PCR was positive with two separate CSF specimens (detected at two separate runs).
December 21, 1993, antibiotic therapy with ceftriaxone (2 g i.v. daily) was started for 4 weeks followed by therapy with oral amoxicillin (500 mg every 8 h) combined with oral probenecid (500 mg every 8 h). On February 1, the antibiotic therapy was stopped because of bloody diarrhoea. Culture and toxn detection for Clostridium difficile were negative. The diarrhoe was cured with oral metronidazole.
On Februray 1, 1994, MRI of the brain showed reduction of abnormal tissue around the operative area. At this time, no enhancement was seen in the walls of the cavity. At a follow-up of 1 year, recovery was observed witho only a slight abnormality in walking. No new symptoms developed.
of Borrelia burgdorferi by polymerase chain
reaction in synovial membrane, but not in synovial fluid from patients
persisting Lyme arthritis after antibiotic therapy.
Priem S, Burmester GR, Kamradt T, Wolbart K, Rittig MG, Krause A. Ann Rheum Dis 1998 Feb;57(2):118-21 PMID: 9613343 PDF
M, acute arthritis left knee. High Lyme IgG. Doxycycline
and diclofenac, and intraarticular dexamethasone.
B. burgdorferi DNA in SF, Ceftriaxone 2g/d, 2 weeks. Arthritis improved significantly but recurred after about six weeks. Treated with ceftriaxone again. Although SF PCR became negative, gonarthritis persisted. A popliteal cyst developed and a bursitis of the left elbow occurred. An arthroscopic synovectomy of the left knee and a bursectomy were performed. Ceftriaxone 2g for 28d, doxycyclin2 200 mg for 30 d.
Case 2: 51y F, 2 month history of bilateral gonarthritis, remembered tickbite and EM-like lesion at the right thigh years ago. IgG positive ELISA & Western Blot and B. burgdorferi PCR in SF positive. Doxycycline 200mg/d for 35d without effect.Ceftriaxone 2g/d for 3 weeks w only moderate success. Two mo after treatement gonarthritis persisted. An arthrocentesis and synovial biopsy was performed.
Case 3: 28y F, subtotal arthroscopic synovectomy of the right knee had been performed elsewhere because of a gonarthritis with pronounced synovial proliferation… persisted for 9 months. … positive Lyme serology both IgM & IgG. Ceftriaxone 2g 14 d. treatment discontinued at day 11 because of an allergic rash. Gonarthritis persisted. PCR positive in SF; doxycycline 200mg/d for 30d. In addition corticosteroid intraarticularly. However only a temporary improvement of the arthritis was seen … Arthroscopy … SF and SM samples.
Case 4: 43y F, bilateral gonarthritis 7 mo, ELISA & Western Blot high IgG, PCR for B. burgdorferi in SF and urine positive. Ceftriaxone 2g 14d without improvement. A few weeks later the patient was seen in another hospital with an acute polyarthritis involving both wrists and several metacarpophalangeal joints and a deterioration of the right gonarthritis. Doxycycline 200mg/d 30d and prednisolone 10-20 mg/d. Again there was no sufficient response … A closed needle arthrocentesis with synovial biopsy of the right knee was performed.
were evaluated 8 to 10 weeks after antibiotic therapy. All were still
and had active arthritis. Urine samples were collected
and within one
and SM specimens were obtained ...
In none of the urine or SF samples could B. burgdorferi DNA be detected, in contrast SM samples was positive.
Patients 1,2,4: cefotaxime 2g x3 3 weeks, followed by six weeks oral doxycycline or minocycline 200mg/d.
Pt. 3: imipenem 1.0g x3 for 2 weeks, doxycycline 200mg six weeks.
In all four patients arthritis
within 4-6 mo and did
not recur at a median
observation period of 18 mo.
No mentioning of any extraarticular symptoms.
plana vitrectomy in Borrelia burgdorferi
Meier P, Blatz R, Gau M, Spencker FB, Wiedemann P. Klin Monatsbl Augenheilkd 1998 Dec;213(6):351-4 PMID: 10048013
Ocular manifestations of Lyme borreliose present with unusual forms of
conjunctivitis, keratitis, optic nerve disease, uveitis, vitritis and
CASE REPORT: A 57-year-old man working as logger in Saxony-Anhalt suffering from an endophthalmitis on his left eye was referred to us. The vision of his left eye was intact light perception and hand motions. The slit-lamp examination revealed severe inflammation of the anterior chamber with hypopyon, posterior synechiae, and opacity of the posterior lens capsule. Funduscopy showed no red reflex, no retinal details. In the local hospital serum analysis was performed and showed in Western-Blot IgM- and IgG-antibodies against Borrelia burgdorferi. Despite of intravenous application of ceftriaxon for 14 days panuveitis persisted, and endophthalmitis developed when antibiotic therapy was finished.
RESULTS: During pars plana vitrectomy a sharply delineated cystic lesion containing yellowish fluid was revealed, and creamy yellow fluid was aspirated. Microscopically in hematoxylin-eosin stained slides of the aspirate structures consistent with Borrelia burgdorferi were found. Postoperatively vision increased to 1/15. Despite of a second intravenous ceftriaxon treatment for 14 days we observed a retinal vasculitis in the follow up of 6 months.
CONCLUSIONS: Despite intravenous ceftriaxon-therapy borrelia burgdorferi must have survived in the vitreous body. Further investigations are required with respect to the use of other antibiotics or immunosuppressives.
burgdorferi detected by culture and PCR in clinical relapse of
disseminated Lyme borreliosis.
Oksi J, Marjamaki M, Nikoskelainen J, Viljanen MK. Ann Med 1999 Jun;31(3):225-32 PMID: 10442678
total of 165 patients with disseminated Lyme
borreliosis (diagnosed in 1990-94, all seropositive except one
patient) were followed after antibiotic treatment.
32/165 (19,4%) had clinical relapse after more than 3 months antibiotic treatment for borreliosis.
In 13/32 (40,6%) could the relapse be verified by either positive PCR (12) and/or positive culture (3) for B. burgdorferi.
2/104 (1,9%) of the asymptomatic had positive PCR. These were not treated and didn't have sign of relapse since, according to personal communication (12/09-2000) with Oksi.
At time of proven relapse 6/13 (46%) were seronegative; 12/13 were seropositive at initial diagnosis, i.e. 5 pts. developed seronegativity despite proven persistence of Borrelia infection!
5/13 (38%) had circulating immunecomplexes, of these 3 were seronegative.
One patient (#10) was seronegative throughout the whole course of illness despite both positive culture and PCR in CSF and positive biopsy and plasma PCR at relapse! - this patient had been treated with ceftriaxone IV 2g for 3 weeks, followed by 24 weeks of doxycycline 100 g bid and amoxicillin 1 week - a total of 28 weeks (6-7 months).
1 patient (8) had been treated for as long as 47 weeks (11 months) including 7 weeks of intravenous ceftriaxone - primary diagnosis was confirmed by positive biopsy and the relapse 44 weeks after treatment confirmed by a positive plasma PCR.
1 patient (2) had relapse 130 weeks after 1. treatment, that had lasted 16 weeks. Pt. was seropositive initially (both IgM and IgG), but seronegative at relapse, relapse confirmed by positive PCR, no history of reinfection in the meantime.
of Borrelia garinii and Borrelia afzelii
in patients with Lyme arthritis.
Hulinska D, Votypka J, Valesova M. Int J Med Microbiol Virol Parasitol Infect Dis 1999 Jul;289(3):301-18 PMID: 10467661
repeatedly detected DNA of Borrelia garinii or B. afzelii and
structures in the blood, joint fluid or in the synovium of 10 patients
Lyme arthritis by means of the polymerase chain reaction and
microscopy at 2-4-month intervals in the course of two years.
All samples were analyzed using primers which amplified the 16S rRNA gene sequence of Borrelia burgdorferi sensu lato and nucleotide sequences for the OspA gene. No cross hybridization occurred with DNA from human cells and with DNA from other bacteria. Capture and labelling with monoclonal antibodies of aggregated antigens, membranes and flagellae were evident in the blood of 7 patients, in 4 synovial membranes and 2 synovial fluids. Borreliae were found in blood capillaries, in collagen and in clusters surrounding inflammatory cells in the synovium of patients with recurrent infections who carried IgM and IgG antibodies to OspA and to 83 kDa core protein.
After significant improvement for several weeks after treatment, arthritis recurred in six patients. Synoviocyte hyperplasia, inflammatory infiltration and concentric adventitial fibroplasia were seen in the synovium of the patients with persisting borreliae. Only two patients were infected with B. afzelii, the others with B. garinii.
arthritis in a 12-year-old patient after a
latency period of 5 years.
Albert S, Schulze J, Riegel H, Brade V. Infection 1999;27(4-5):286-8 PMID: 10885847
Lyme arthritis (LA) may be confused with other rheumatic diseases, particularly in the absence of a history of erythema migrans (EM). We report the case of a 12-year-old patient who developed a large effusion of the right knee joint. The titer for antinuclear antibodies was 1:80 and the test for rheumatoid factor was negative. Investigations for antibody response to Borrelia burgdorferi demonstrated remarkable elevation of IgG antibody and no specific IgM response.These results were confirmed by immunoblotting reactivity with the bands p83/100, p58, p43, p41, p39, OspA, p30, OspC, p21, and p17. We subsequently learned that the child had suffered a tick bite followed by an EM 5 years earlier and had been treated with trimethoprim/sulfamethoxazole at that time. The patient now was given intravenous ceftriaxone, 2 g daily for 14 days. In the absence of clinical improvement 3 weeks later a knee joint aspiration was performed which resulted in a positive polymerase chain reaction (PCR) test for B. burgdorferi DNA (OspA) in the synovial fluid. The patient fully recovered 2 months later without further treatment. The case indicates that the latency period between EM and onset of LA may last up to 5 years. In addition to serologic test methods, analysis of synovial fluid using PCR may be decisive for making the final diagnosis of LA.
of Borrelia burgdorferi sensu lato in patients with Lyme
Honegr K, Hulinska D, Dostal V, Gebousky P, Hankova E, Horacek J, Vyslouzil L, Havlasova J. Epidemiol Mikrobiol Imunol 2001 Feb;50(1):10-16 PMID: 11233667
In 18 patients with Lyme borreliosis the authors proved the persistence of Borrelia burgdorferi sensu lato by detection of the causal agent by immune electron microscopy or of its DNA by PCR in plasma or cerebrospinal fluid after an interval of 4-68 months. Clinical manifestations common in Lyme borreliosis were present in only half the patients, in the remainder non-specific symptoms were found. In nine subjects with confirmed Borrelia burgdorferi sensu lato in the cerebrospinal fluid the cytological and biochemical finding was normal. Examination of antibodies by the ELISA method was negative in 7 of 18 patients during the first examination and in 12 of 18 during the second examination. In all negative examinations the specific antibodies were assessed by the Western blot or ELISA method after liberation from the immunocomplexes. In the authors' opinion it is advisable to examine repeatedly plasma and other biological material from potentially affected organs by PCR and subjects with persisting or relapsing complaints after the acute form of Lyme borreliosis as well as to examine cerebrospinal fluid in case on non-specific symptoms and concurrent pathic EEG or MR findings.
[might be the same 18 cases described below by Honegr et al in 2004 ?]
term and repeated electron microscopy and PCR detection of Borrelia
sensu lato after an antibiotic treatment.
Honegr K, Hulinska D, Beran J, Dostal V, Havlasova J, Cermakova Z. Cent Eur J Public Health. 2004 Mar;12(1):6-11. PMID: 15068199 PDF
diagnosis of Lyme
disease in 18 patients has been proved
of Borrelia burgdorferi sensu lato when using immunoelectron microscopy
detecting its nucleic acid by PCR in the plasma or the cerebrospinal
The positive results occurred in the plasma or in the
in the period of 4-68 months after an antibiotic treatment.
The typical clinical manifestations of Lyme disease were observed in 9 patients and non-specific symptoms in another 9 patients.
According to presented results we can recommend repeated examination using PCR of the plasma and other biological specimens in the individuals with persistent or recurring complaints after an acute form of Lyme disease and its antibiotic treatment. Also examination of the cerebrospinal fluid with non-specific symptoms and simultaneously displayed pathology electroencephalogram and/or magnetic resonance imaging findings can be advantageous.
[might be the same 18 cases described above by Honegr et al in 2001, in Czech?]
isolation of Borrelia lusitaniae from a human patient
Collares-Pereira M, Couceiro S, Franca I, Kurtenbach K, Schafer SM, Vitorino L, Goncalves L, Baptista S, Vieira ML, Cunha C. J Clin Microbiol. 2004 March; 42(3): 1316-1318. PMID: 15004107 PDF
"A 46-year-old woman from the Lisbon area in Portugal presented with skin lesions on her left thigh that had persisted for approximately 10 years. These chronic skin lesions were characterized by two ill-defined erythematous macules associated with a local diffuse infiltration of the subcutaneous tissues."
… used culture for 4 weeks at 32 degr. C and PCR with multiple other strains for comparison.
Borrelia was successfully isolated from the skin lesion of the human patient. The sequence of the intergenic spacer sequence of the B. lusitaniae human isolate (strain PoHL1) is shown in Fig. 1.”
"In conclusion, for this
human case, the described weak
serological response*, which is present in a high
percentage of our patients with unspecific and long-lasting skin
manifestations, suggests a clinical pattern for B. lusitaniae
different from those for other Borrelia spp. in the
Portuguese population examined so far."
* according to personal correspondence with da Franca this patient IS the very same as described below by same authors (i.e. the clinical case story); according to that, this patient was SERONEGATIVE on more serology tests?! - and despite diplaying symptoms of ACA for 10 years!
valaisiana in cerebrospinal fluid
Diza E, Papa A, Vezyri E, Tsounis S, Milonas I, Antoniadis A. Emerg Infect Dis. 2004 Sep;10(9):1692-3. PMID: 15503409 PDF
We report the genetic detection of B. valaisiana in the CSF of a 61-year-old man with a history of spastic paraparesis, which is strong clinical evidence of advanced neuroborreliosis. Symptoms, mainly difficulty in walking, began approximately 10 years earlier, with a slow progressive course of neuroborreliosis. His medical history showed an unidentified sexually transmitted disease in 1982, an undefined episode of arthritis in the lower limbs in 1990, and a nonspecific rash in the genitals in 1995. The patient lived in South Africa from 1961 to 1997 and visited Thassos Island in northern Greece every year. The neurologic examination demonstrated an intense pyramidal spasticity in the lower limbs and moderate weakness (Medical Research Council grade 3) of the proximal muscles. Serial magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of the brain showed small hyperintensities in the periventricular area on T2-weighted images; MRI of the spinal cord showed no abnormalities. Multiple sclerosis, B12 deficiency, human T-cell lymphotrophic virus-1 infection, structural inflammatory lesions of the spinal cord, motor neuron disease, and hereditary spastic paraplegia have been excluded.
The patient was treated occasionally with intravenous penicillin G, as well as with corticosteroids, but no clinical improvement was achieved. Venereal disease reaction level was negative and all tests for syphilis in CSF were negative." ....
is difficult to diagnose by serologic evaluation and Western blot
interpretation. In our patient, no
intrathecal antibodies were produced to support clinical suspicion of
disease. The low antibody titers could be attributed to
antigenic variation between B. valaisiana and B. burgdorferi sensu
stricto, which was used as antigen because
no commercial kit is specific for B. valaisiana."
synovitis in children with Lyme arthritis:
two unusual cases. An immunogenetic
Hendrickx G, De Boeck H, Goossens A, Demanet C, Vandenplas Y. Eur J Pediatr. 2004 Nov;163(11):646-50. Epub 2004 Jul 8. PMID: 15503133
We report on two patients with a persistent Lyme
arthritis. In addition both had a peculiar disease history.
The first patient had oligoarticular juvenile idiopathic arthritis in remission. Five months after an infected tick bite, she developed a relapse of arthritis in the same knee. We considered Lyme borreliosis as the possible trigger for this reactivation.
The disease history of the second patient was that of a classical non-responder. After extensive antibiotic treatment osteolytic lesions became visible. MRI images suggested an erosive arthropathy and arthroscopy was used to investigate possible erosive arthritis. Studies on collected material made us consider the following hypothesis. Despite demonstration of a spirochete fragment in a synovial biopsy, the patient recovered without additional antibiotic treatment.
CONCLUSION: delay of antibiotic treatment after appearance of erythema migrans may cause systemic spread of the antigen and predispose to Lyme arthritis. If intra-articular steroids are considered when spontaneous resolution of Lyme arthritis does not occur, magnetic resonance imaging of the affected joint, prior to administration, may provide additional information. The success of synovectomy may be related to removal of undegraded antigenic material which may prolong the inflammation.
borreliosis in Portugal caused
by Borrelia lusitaniae? Clinical report on the first
patient with a positive skin isolate.
da Franca I, Santos L, Mesquita T, Collares-Pereira M, Baptista S, Vieira L, Viana I, Vale E, Prates C. Wien Klin Wochenschr. 2005 Jun;117(11-12):429-32. PMID: 16053200
BACKGROUND: Borrelia lusitaniae was isolated from an Ixodes ricinus tick in Portugal in 1993 for the first time. Further, this borrelia genospecies has been found in ixodid ticks collected around the coasts of southern Portugal and North Africa. Its reservoir has not been defined yet. B. lusitaniae was isolated once until now from a patient with a long standing and expanding skin disorder.
METHODS: A 46-year-old
presented with a skin lesion on the left thigh which had evolved slowly
years. The patient
headaches, and cardiac rhythm
disturbances. History of tick bites was
negative nor had the patient ever noticed a skin lesion
comparable with erythema chronicum migrans.
Skin biopsies were taken for histological evaluation, culture and DNA detection. Antibodies to borrelia were searched by indirect immunofluorescence assay and Western-blot.
RESULTS: A bilateral carpal tunnel syndrome and local synovitis was diagnosed.Dermato-histology was normal, serology was negative.
Spirochaetal organisms were cultured from a skin biopsy and identified as B. lusitaniae. The patient improved after a 2-week course of intravenous ceftriaxone; the skin lesions did not expand further.
CONCLUSIONS: This culture confirmed skin infection by B. lusitaniae in a patient from Portugal suggests an additional human pathogen out of the B. burgdorferi sensu lato complex in Europe, particularly in Portugal.
Correspondence with da Franca; this IS the same CASE on which the confirming ANTIGEN TESTS were described in detail in above mentioned article by Collares-Pereira et al.
December 2001, a
presented with two asymptomatic skin
lesions on the posterior lateral
area of the left thigh. She reported that the lesions had arisen about
10 years before. More recently she had observed an
increase in the
perimeter of the left thigh. She further reported persistent headaches,
paraesthesia in the hands, cramps in the trunk, especially at night,
and palpitations of the heart. One year ago she was
troubled with a
subdural haematoma which occurred without any apparent traumatic cause.
could not recall a tick bite nor had she ever noticed a skin lesion
according to erythema chronicum migrans.
The skin inspection revealed an area of slight depigmentation on the left thigh where two ill-defined erythematous macules stood out (Fig. 1). Although there was some local, discrete, arborising telangiectasia, there was no atrophy, sclerosis, depression or other skin surface alteration. The circumference of this thigh was about 1.7cm longer than the other one. The skin surface could not be wrinkled, and pitting appeared when it was pinched (Fig. 2). Circumscribed scleroderma (morphea) and acrodermatitis chronica atrophicans (ACA) were considered in the differential diagnosis. The neurological examination revealed a slight decrease of sensitivity and muscular strength in the extremities.
Materials and methods
Skin biopsies were taken from the edge of the lesions for histopathological examination, for culture of borrelia, and for borrelia DNA detection by PCR. Serum antibodies against borrelia were searched by indirect immunofluorescence assay (IFA), and by immunoblot using B. lusitaniae, B. garinii and B. afzelii as antigens . Additionally, blood was submitted for routine testing of medical laboratory parameters. Motor and sensory nerve conduction studies were performed on the median nerves, ulnar nerves, peroneal nerves and cutaneous plantar nerves. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of the head, the spine and the wrists was performed. A Holter's dynamic electrocardiography was also carried out.
The histopathology of lesional skin revealed normal epidermis, mild dermal telangiectasia and sporadic perivascular lymphocytes (Fig. 3). No spirochaetes were detected in the sections.
Culture of the skin samples was positive for borrelia and genotyping identified the genospecies B. lusitaniae .
No serum antibodies were detected by IFA, and IgM and IgG immunoblots were negative .
The nerve conduction study revealed a slight focal demyelination of the median nerves on the wrists, but no evidence of polineuropathy. MRI of both wrists revealed bilateral synovitis of the radiocarpal joint. Blood tests and electrocardiography yielded normal results. The patient was treated with intravenous ceftriaxone, 2 g daily for two weeks. Thereafter the clinical conditions of the patient improved, and the skin lesions did not expand further. Soon after the administration of ceftriaxone the patient had a febrile rash with myalgia and worsening of the headaches which disappeared the next day."
susceptibility testing of Borrelia
burgdorferi sensu lato isolates cultured
from patients with erythema migrans before
and after antimicrobial chemotherapy.
Hunfeld KP, Ruzic-Sabljic E, Norris DE, Kraiczy P, Strle F. Antimicrob Agents Chemother. 2005 Apr;49. PMID: 15793100 PDF
Clinical treatment failures have been reported to occur in early Lyme borreliosis (LB) for many suitable antimicrobial agents. Investigations of possible resistance mechanisms of the Borrelia burgdorferi complex must analyze clinical isolates obtained from LB patients, despite their receiving antibiotic treatment. Here, borrelial isolates obtained from five patients with erythema migrans (EM) before the start of antibiotic therapy and again after the conclusion of treatment were investigated. The 10 isolates were characterized by restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis and plasmid profile analysis and subjected to susceptibility testing against a variety of antimicrobial agents including those used for initial chemotherapy. Four out of five patients were infected by the same genospecies (Borrelia afzelii, n = 3; Borrelia garinii, n = 1) at the site of the EM lesion before and after antimicrobial therapy. In one patient the genospecies of the initial isolate (B. afzelii) differed from that of the follow-up isolate (B. garinii). No significant changes in the in vitro susceptibilities became obvious for corresponding clinical isolates before the start and after the conclusion of antimicrobial therapy. This holds true for the antimicrobial agents used for specific chemotherapy of the patients, as well as for any of the additional agents tested in vitro. Our study substantiates borrelial persistence in some EM patients at the site of the infectious lesion despite antibiotic treatment over a reasonable time period. Borrelial persistence, however, was not caused by increasing MICs or minimal borreliacidal concentrations in these isolates. Therefore, resistance mechanisms other than acquired resistance to antimicrobial agents should be considered in patients with LB resistant to treatment.
The study protocols included initial biopsy of EM at first visit before the institution of antibiotic therapy and a second biopsy at the same anatomic site approximately 2 months (range, 1.3 to 3 months) later as reported elsewhere (39, 40). Biopsy samples were taken under sterile conditions and immediately cultured in modified Barbour-Stoenner-Kelly (BSK) medium at 33°C for 9 weeks as described previously (27).
19 out of 1,148 (1.7%)
EM patients diagnosed during the 6-year-period spirochetes
could be cultured not only from the site of EM before the
start of empirical antibiotic therapy but again after the conclusion of
treatment from the original site of the lesion.
Stock cultures of 10 clinical isolates obtained from five immunocompetent patients out of these 19 individuals were still available for analysis in this in vitro study.
discussion: Clinically, treatment failures
occur in 5 to 10% of EM patients (12, 34). Macrolides fail
more often than beta-lactam agents and tetracyclines do (9). Here,
the existence of persistent borrelial infection is further
seropositive and seronegative EM patients (Table 1)
despite highly active antimicrobial chemotherapy.
Our observations corroborate with the findings of Bockenstedt et al., which could demonstrate borrelial persistence in the mouse model by use of xenodiagnosis in 4 out of 10 animals up to 3 months after prolonged therapy with doxycycline and ceftriaxone (5). Our findings in antibiotically treated EM patients indeed suggest that the population of spirochetes detected after chemotherapy may genetically differ from the initial bacterial population initiating the infection. This observation is in accordance with recent findings that survival of infectious borrelial isolates in antibiotically treated mice is correlated with genetic recombination and diminished levels or complete loss of lp25 and lp28-1, plasmids that are known to carry genes which are important for the infectiousness of borreliae (5). Such attenuated residual borreliae were no longer infectious when transmitted to new mammalian hosts (5).
From table 1:
given before the second positive culture of
Borrelia burgdorferi in the 5 patients:
1: Ceftriaxone, 1 dose, 2 g, i.v., 14 days
2: Amoxicillin, 3 doses, 500 mg, p.o., 14 days
3: Cefuroxime, 2 doses, 500 mg, p.o., 14 days
4: Cefuroxime, 2 doses, 500 mg, p.o., 14 days
5: Azithromycin, 2 doses, 500 mg, p.o., 1 day; 1 dose, 500 mg, p.o., 4 days
tick bite and onset of EM: 10-26 days (2 no known tickbite).
Time between onset of symptoms and treatment: 1-11 days; 11 days were for pt#2, who remembered a tickbite and had a large EM sized 10x16 cm; reason for delay in treatment?
Three of the 5 patients with culture verified EM were both IgM and IgG SERONEGATIVE (early treatment).
Time (days) between start of treatment and second biopsy: 39-69 days. Time (wks) between second biopsy and positive culture 2.5 to 6 wks.
TOP European American Animal
adult respiratory distress syndrome in a patient
with Lyme disease.
Kirsch M, Ruben FL, Steere AC, Duray PH, Norden CW, Winkelstein A. JAMA1988 May 13; 259(18): 2737-9 PMID: 335724
A 67-year-old woman who lived on a farm near Pittsburgh first noted lethargy, weakness, lower-extremity stiffness, and myalgias on May 16, 1986, one week after a weekend trip to the Maryland shore. Soon thereafter, a dry cough, swelling of her hands, fever, anorexia, and a rash on her extremities and trunk developed. Although she had no known history of a tick bite, a presumptive diagnosis of Rocky Mountain spotted fever was made, and a two-week course of tetracycline hydrochloride, 250 mg orally four times a day, was prescribed.
Because of persistent symptoms, she was referred to Montefiore Hospital in Pittsburgh. Examination showed a maculopapular eruption on her trunk and hands. Although antibody titers for Rocky Mountain spotted fever were negative, both the IgM and IgG antibody titers in response to the Lyme disease spirochete Borrelia burgdorferi were markedly elevated (Table), as determined by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay.2 She completed her tetracycline course without improvement in her condition.
She was admitted to the hospital on June 17, 1986. Her temperature was 36.7oC. Liver function test results were abnormal (lactic dehydrogenase [LDH], 419 U/L; aspartate aminotransferase [ASAT], 639 U/L; alanine aminotransferase [ALAT], 418 U/L; and alkaline phosphatase, 223 U/L), but results of the remainder of the admission studies, including a serum VDRL test, chest roentgenogram, and electrocardiogram, were unremarkable. A skin biopsy specimen revealed nonspecific inflammatory changes. Because of the lack of response to tetracycline, she was given a ten-day course of intravenous penicillin G potassium, 5 million U every six hours. Her fevers resolved, and her rash, joint complaints, and liver enzyme abnormalities improved (LDH, 338 U/L; ASAT, 184 U/L; ALAT, 111 U/L; and alkaline phosphatase, 198 U/L). She was discharged on June 28.
At home, her rash worsened, and periorbital edema developed. Her constitutional symptoms persisted, and she was readmitted to the hospital five days later. Examination revealed an oral temperature of 38.1oC, a pulse rate of 112 beats per minute, and respirations of 20/min. In addition to the maculopapular rash and periorbital edema, there was moderate swelling and tenderness over the carpal and interphalangeal joints. There was no muscle tenderness or pedal edema, and the lungs were clear. The white blood cell count was 6.0 x 109/L (6.0 x 103/mm3); the erythrocyte sedimentation rate (Wintrobe) was 47 mm/h; and liver and muscle enzyme concentrations were elevated (LDH, 508 U/L; ASAT, 429 U/L; ALAT, 162 U/L; alkaline phosphatase, 286 U/L; and creatine kinase, 279 U/L). A chest roentgenogram showed atelectasis at the left base (Fig 1). The level of immune complexes was shown to be elevated by the C1q binding assay result of 36% (norms), <13%) and by the Raji cell assay result of 315 mg of aggregated human gamma globulin equivalents per liter (normal, <50 mg of aggregated human gamma globulin equivalents per liter). Serum cryoglobulins were absent. Antinuclear antibody was present in low titer (1:10), and rheumatoid factor was positive (1:40). The level of the C3 component of complement was mildly decreased, at 0.85 g/L (35 g/dl) (normal range, 1.15 to 1.85 g/L [115 to 185 mg/dl]). Titers for hepatitis A, hepatitis B, cytomegalovirus, Epstein-Barr virus, Trichinella, Legionella pneumophila, and febrile agglutinins were negative. The patient was given a second course of intravenous penicillin C potassium, 5 million U every six hours, and enteric coated aspirin 650 mg orally every four hours.
Initially, her rash, edema, and arthralgias improved, but her marked lethargy and dry cough persisted. On her tenth day in the hospital, bibasilar rales were noted, and a chest roentgenogram demonstrated new findings of bibasilar atelectasis with bilateral peripheral infiltrates. Prednisone therapy, 20 mg orally three times a day, was begun. While her rash and edema improved, her liver and muscle enzyme abnormalities worsened. An abdominal computed tomographic scan showed a nonhomogeneous liver and was otherwise unremarkable.
Four days later, her oral temperature rose to 38.9oC, and her respirations were 34/mm. Increased rales were present bilaterally. An arterial blood gas test done while the patient was breathing 35% 02 showed the following values: Arterial oxygen pressure, 68 mm Hg; arterial carbon dioxide pressure, 27 mm Hg; and pH, 7.55. The white blood cell count was 12.4 x 109/L (12.4 10 103/mm3), with 0.04 (4%) band forms. A chest roentgenogram showed diffuse, bilateral, patchy infiltrates (Fig 1). Blood and urine cultures showed no growth. Lyme disease antibody titers were still markedly elevated (Table). Immunoblotting demonstrated IgG antibodies against at least 14 polypeptides of B burgdorferi, including the 31-kilodalton outer-membrane component. Nafcillin and tobramycin therapy was started empirically.
On the following day, during bronchoalveolar lavage, the patient became tachypnoic and cyanotic and underwent intubation. A chest roentgenogram now showed bilateral central infiltrates. The patient was given intravenous trimethoprim with sulfamethoxazole, and nafcillin therapy was discontinued. She became increasingly more hypoxemic, requiring a positive end-expiratory pressure of 15 cm H2O and a fraction of inspired oxygen in the range of 0.8 to 0.9. On her 19th day in the hospital, an open-lung biopsy specimen revealed severe, acute, diffuse alveolar damage, compatible with the adult respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS). There was no evidence of tumor, infection, or vasculitis. She became progressively more hypoxemic and hypotensive, and she died six days later.
The cause of death was diffuse alveolar damage of the lungs (ARDS). Additional findings were cardiomegaly (370 g with borderline right ventricular hypertrophy (0.3 cm), fatty liver (1600 g), and acute tubular necrosis of the kidneys. Lymph nodes showed a transformed lymphocytic response, and, when Dieterle silver stain was used,3 spirochetes compatible with B burgdorferi infection were demonstrated (Fig 2). Lung tissue was submitted for virus isolation and was found to be negative for influenza A and B, parainfluenza, respiratory syncytial virus, adenovirus, and coxoackievirus. Antibodies to Leptospira canicola and Leptospira icterohaemorrhoragiae antibodies were present at less than 1:8 by complement fixation testing and were not detectable by direct agglutination testing using serum from July 21, 1986, three days before the patient died.
After the first description of Lyme disease in 1975, the clinical spectrum was expanded to include cardiac and neurologic features.4 This disorder is now recognized to be a multisystemic disease that triggers a complex immune response to a spirochetal infection.
The patient described herein presented with cough, fever, a diffuse rash, and myositis, and she also had abnormal liver function test results. Her hospital course was essentially characterized by progressive respiratory failure and fatal ARDS. Levels of IgM and IgG antibodies were markedly increased in response to B burgdorferi, the agent that causes Lyme disease. This level of titers has been shown to exhibit cross-reactivity in patients with syphilis or relapsing fever. We excluded syphilis with a nonreactive VDRL test and relapsing fever with immunoblotting studies. Antibodies were demonstrated to 14 polypeptides of B burgdorferi, including the 31-kilodalton polypeptide, a pattern thought to be specific for Lyme disease.5 In addition, lymph node sections examined after the patients death demonstrated spirochetes morphologically compatible with B burgdorferi. We are confident that the serologic and histologic evidence described supports the diagnosis of Lyme disease.
The clinical features of our patient were, however, highly atypical for Lyme disease. Her rash was generalized and prominent on her hands. This distribution has not previously been reported in Lyme disease and contrasts with erythema chronicum migrans, the unique clinical marker for this disorder.6 Although mild hepatitis has been described,6 markedly abnormal liver enzyme levels, myositis, and edema of the hands and face are not characteristic of Lyme disease. Most important was her progressive and fatal respiratory failure. The only respiratory symptom described in human Lyme disease is a nonproductive cough, although spirochetes have been demonstrated in the lungs of experimentally infected hamsters.7 Since it is recognized that ARDS follows a wide variety of predisposing conditions we believe that Lyme disease triggered this fatal complication.
How can we explain our patients variant clinical syndrome? This case is atypical in its presentation, course, response to therapy, and outcome. This patient received a course tetracycline followed by two courses of high-dose intravenous penicillin, without improvement. Both of these antibiotic regimens are considered to be established antispirochetal therapy for Lyme disease. This suggests that the spirochete was particularly virulent, that the host defenses were impaired, or that the disease state no longer solely depended on live spirochetes for its expression. We do not believe that our patient was immunocompromised. The mechanism by which B burgdorferi causes Lyme disease is still under study. It is unclear whether certain manifestations of Lyme disease require a live spirochete for continued disease activity or whether they result from immune-mediated mechanisms.1 Although spirochetes were identified in lymph nodes, the transformed lymphocytic response, the presence of circulating immune complexes and the progression of disease despite antibiotic treatment indicate an immune-mediated disease.
Lyme disease has become a prevalent and serious infection. In addition to chronic arthritis,8 this disease has been shown to be the cause of fatal myocarditis,9 panophthalmitis leading to blindness,10 fetal death,11 and central nervous system syndromes suggestive of demyelination.12To these complications we add respiratory failure and ARDS, which are refractory to known therapy. Although Lyme disease is endemic in the Northeast, the Midwest, and the Far West of the United States, it has been reported throughout the country.13
With an incubation period that ranged from three to 12 days6 and no documented tick bite, we are uncertain whether our patient contracted the disease in Maryland or in western Pennsylvania.
We urge physicians throughout the United States to consider the multisystemic features of Lyme disease and to recognize its lethal potential.
of refractory chronic Lyme arthritis with
Schoen RT, Aversa JM, Rahn DW, Steere AC. Arthritis Rheum 1991 Aug; 34(8): 1056-60 PMID: 1859481
18/20 patients received oral or i.v. antibiotic treatment most both, but treatment drug, dose and duration not specified ...
[thus 2/20 (10%) did NOT receive any antibiotic treatment (?), which makes the title 'refractory' a bit inappropiate IMO!].
Synovia from 12/20 [60%] patients have been analyzed in detail and were similar to 12 rheumatoid synovia used for comparison … moderate-to-marked synovial cell hyperplasia, vascular proliferation, and mononuclear cell infiltration, sometimes with pseudolymphoid follicles ..
In 6/12 patients w/ Lyme arthritis, but in none of those w/ rheumatoid arthritis, a few spirochetes and globular antigen deposits were seen in and around blood vessels in areas of lymphocytic infiltration [i.e. 6/20 (30%) had proven persistent infection in the joint. The paper doesn't tell if 2 of these patients were those that didn't receive antibiotics, but at least 4(-6) obviously had persistent infection despite previous antibiotic treatment.]
80% had resolution of joint inflammation .. and they have not had recurrences during a followup period of 3-8 y …
15% of these patients all of whom were more disabled preoperatively, had no further synovitis, but still had mild functional limitations at long-term followup.
Only [!!!] 20% of the patients had persisitent or recurrent synovitis
[is synovectomy a certain cure for a persistent systemic borrelia infection?]
Authors say they did not find symptoms of extraarticular Lyme borreliosis ... but 1 had facial palsy ….
And the postoperative assessment only includes joint examination not a neurological examination … a (rheumatological) focus problem ??
Attempts to do culture or PCR were not done.
Treatment Failure of Cefotaxime and
Minocycline in a Case of Lyme Meningoencephalomyelitis in the US.
Liegner KB, Rosenkilde CE, Campbell GL, Guam TJ, Dennis DT. 1992 V Int Conf Lb abs #63
1987, a 37-year-old woman living in Westchester County, NY,
paraparesis, bilateral Babinski reflexes, and cranial nerve and bulbar
dysfunction characterized by dysphagia, dysphonia, diplopia, absent gag
and dysfunction of bowel and bladder control. CSF contained 19 WBC/mm
Borrelia burgdorferi (Bb) in serum was negative. No
was established despite an extensive workup. Symptoms and signs
worsened gradually from 1988 to present. There was a past history of
splenectomy for idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura diagnosed in 1975.
frontal region and right basal ganglia were abnormal on brain MRI. In
1990 CSF contained 6 WBC/mm3 (93% lymphs), but no oligoclonal bands or
basic protein. Paired
tests for antibodies to Bb and PCR for Bb-specific oligonucleotides in
negative. An empiric 21-day course of cefotaxime (3g/l2 hr
January, 1990 with no clear clinical benefit.
treatment, CSF contained 9 WBC/mm3 (93% lymphs). Four
months of minocycline (200 mg/day
p.o.) begun in November, 1990 also yielded no clear clinical benefit.
In December, 1990 a T-cell stimulation
test with Bb antigens was strongly positive.
In December, 1991 CSF contained 6 WBC/mm3 (89% lymphs) and elevated
serum and CSF samples
for antibodies to Bb, with a CSF-to-serum index of 1.04. Culture of
this CSF specimen in BSK-Il yielded a strain of Bb.
Culture-confirmed treatment failures have been
previously reported for three Lyme neuroborreliosis cases in Europe.
The present case apparently is the first of this type to be reported
from the United
of Borrelia burgdorferi Antigens in
Patients receiving Long-Term Antibiotic Therapy.
Drulle J, Eiras E. 1992 V Int Conf Lb abs#70E
Patients, previously diagnosed with Lyme Disease and treated
with long-term antibiotic therapy provided samples of urine, spinal
fluid, synovial fluid, breast milk or tears. All but 3 of
the patients were symptomatic at the time of the testing.
Samples were tested by employing a polyclonal antibody tagged with colloidal gold which is specific to an 83 kilodalton vescicular protein, also known as a "bleb" and thought to be specific to Borrelia burgdorferi.
In 13 patients antigen was detected [13/25 = 52%]. Persistence of antigen may be related to persisting infection or may represent lengthy clearance of dead spirochetal debris.
Molecular detection of persistent
in a man with dermatomyositis.
Fraser DD, Kong LI, Miller FW. Clin Exp Rheumatol 1992 Jul-Aug; 10(4): 387-90. PMID: 1395222
A 40-year-old white man with a several year history of various immunologic disorders, including anti-Jo-1 autoantibody positive dermatomyositis, developed clinical Lyme disease after being biten by a tick. The patient was treated with oral tetracycline and his initial symptoms resolved; however, he suffered an exacerbation of his muscle disease which was difficult to control despite cytotoxic therapy. Antibiotic therapy was reinstituted after Borrelia burgdorferi was detected in the patient's peripheral blood leukocytes by the polymerase chain reaction (PCR). All serologic, T-cell stimulation, and western blot analyses, however, were negative. The patient's disease responded to oral ampicillin, probenecid therapy and concurrent cytotoxic therapy. Subsequent leukocyte PCR testing has been negative for the causative agent of Lyme disease. This case may provide an example of the in vivo immuno-modulatory effects of spirochetes in human autoimmune disease. In addition, this case emphasizes the potential clinical utility of PCR technology in evaluating the persistent sero-negative Lyme disease which may occur in immunocompromised individuals.
burgdorferi myositis: report of eight patients.
Reimers CD, de Koning J, Neubert U, Preac Mursic V, Koster JG, Muller Felber W, Pongratz DE, Duray PH. J Neurol 1993 May; 240(5): 278-83. PMID: 8326331
patients with histologic proven myositis of which
one was seronegative - one fatal case
5/8 had normal CK and none (2) or slight abnormality in other laboratory findings (3 had ESR in range 26-38) see table 2
2 had normal EMG
Patients 4 & 6 were culture positive for borrelia in skin, but not in muscle biopsies. Treated with antibiotics 10-14 days, patient 1 had persistent fatique, patient 8 died from cardiac arrest caused by B. burgdorferi myocarditis, myocardial inflammation at autopsy, where spirochetes were demonstrated.
septic arthritis caused by Borrelia burgdorferi.
Battafarano DF, Combs JA, Enzenauer RJ, Fitzpatrick JE. Clin Orthop 1993 Dec(297):238-41. PMID: 8242938
Chronic arthritis occurs in 10% of Lyme disease patients. A patient had chronic septic Lyme arthritis of the knee for seven years despite multiple antibiotic trials and multiple arthroscopic and open synovectomies. Spirochetes were documented in synovium and synovial fluid (SF). Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) analysis of the SF was consistent with Borrelia infection. Persistent infection should be excluded with silver stains and cultures in any patient with chronic monoarticular arthritis and a history of Lyme disease.
of Borrelia burgdorferi DNA by polymerase chain reaction in
synovial fluid from patients with Lyme arthritis [see
Nocton JJ, Dressler F, Rutledge BJ, Rys PN, Persing DH, Steere AC. N Engl J Med 1994 Jan 27; 330(4):229-34. PMID: 8272083
burgdorferi is difficult to detect in synovial fluid, which
understanding of the pathogenesis of Lyme arthritis, particularly when
arthritis persists despite antibiotic therapy.
METHODS. Using the polymerase chain reaction (PCR), we attempted to detect B. burgdorferi DNA in joint-fluid samples obtained over a 17-year period. The samples were tested in two separate laboratories with four sets of primers and probes, three of which target plasmid DNA that encodes outer-surface protein A (OspA).
RESULTS. B. burgdorferi DNA was detected in 75 of 88 patients with Lyme arthritis (85 percent) and in none of 64 control patients. Each of the three OspA primer-probe sets was sensitive, and the results were moderately concordant in the two laboratories (kappa = 0.54 to 0.73). Of 73 patients with Lyme arthritis that was untreated or treated with only short courses of oral antibiotics, 70 (96 percent) had positive PCR results. In contrast, of 19 patients who received either parenteral antibiotics or long courses of oral antibiotics (> or = 1 month), only 7 (37 percent) had positive tests (P < 0.001). None of these seven patients had received more than two months of oral antibiotic treatment or more than three weeks of intravenous antibiotic treatment. Of 10 patients with chronic arthritis (continuous joint inflammation for one year or more) despite multiple courses of antibiotics, 7 had consistently negative tests in samples obtained three months to two years after treatment.
CONCLUSIONS. PCR testing can detect B. burgdorferi DNA in synovial fluid. This test may be able to show whether Lyme arthritis that persists after antibiotic treatment is due to persistence of the spirochete.
[NOTE: Priem et al. (PMID: 9613343) demonstrated that borrelia may be found in synovial membranes in persistent borrelia arthritis, despite that simultaneaous synovial fluid was negative for borrelia-antigen !!]
of Borrelia burgdorferi despite antibiotic
Patmas MA. J Spiro Tick Diseases 1994;1:101
To the Editor:
It has been suggested that Lyme disease may trigger fibromyalgia and that antibiotic therapy beyond 30 days is almost always unnecessary . Recently, two cases demonstrating persistence of Borrelia burgdorferi despite lengthy antibiotic treatment were noted.
In October 1991, a 35-year-old Caucasian female, registered nurse, was referred for evaluation. She had reported a lesion compatible with erythema chronicum migrans about one year earlier. After a short course of oral antibiotics, she noted fatigue, myalgia, and arthralgias and was given 2 weeks of intravenous ceftriaxone 1 g daily with resolution of her symptoms. Over the next several months, however, her symptoms gradually returned. An ELISA titer was elevated, and she was started on ceftriaxone 2 g intravenously daily. After 10 days, the patient developed a vigorous Jarisch-Herxheimer reaction and was referred to the author. The patient was switched to cefotaxime 3 g intravenously every 12 hours with improvement in symptoms. After 6 weeks, the intravenous cefotaxime was changed to oral clarithromycin 500 mg daily for 6 more weeks with complete resolution of all signs and symptoms. One week later, the patient discovered that she was 1 month pregnant and, after a normal gestation, delivered a healthy male infant. The placenta was examined at Brigham and Women's Hospital in Boston, Massachusetts, where several spirochetes were noted in perivascular and intervillous spaces on modified Dieterle silver stain.
A 47-year-old Caucasian female was well until an untreated tick bite in 1985. She subsequently developed a progressive arthritis diagnosed as rheumatoid. After failing treatment with nonsteroidal anti-inflammatories and remittive agents, the author saw the patient for the first time in l990. Aspiration of fluid from the right knee was positive by specific antibody ratio for Lyme disease at the University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey-Robert Wood Johnson University Hospital Lyme Disease Research Center. The patient was started on ceftriaxone 2 g intravenously daily for 4 weeks. She had a significant objective response to treatment but quickly relapsed after it was discontinued. A second 4-week course of ceftriaxone was given with only moderate improvement. The patient then sought treatment at several university centers, where she received experimental treatment for rheumatoid arthritis including monoclonal antibody therapy. There was no improvement in her condition. By July 1992, the patient developed bilateral aseptic necrosis of the hips. A right total hip replacement was performed and histopathologic examination revealed several spirochetes on modified Dieterle silver stain of synovial tissue performed at the Brigham and Women's Hospital. The patient was then started on continuous oral antibiotic treatment with azithromycin 250 mg daily. Approximately 6 months later, the patient underwent left total knee replacement and once again spirochete-like structures were observed in synovial tissue on modified Dieterle silver stain.
cases suggest that despite lengthy courses of both intravenous and oral
antibiotics, Borrelia burgdorferi may persist. The presumption that
symptoms are due to fibromyalgia may not always be true and is not
simply because a patient has received 30 days of treatment. Careful
histopathologic examination by modified Dieterle silver stain may
PCR Positivity in a Patient Being Treated for Lyme Disease
Keszler K, Tilton RC. J Spiro Tick Diseases 1995; 2:57-58.
contracting a present illness, 30-year-old white female occupational
was healthy and active. She bicycled regularly in a Lyme endemic area.
early July 1994 she had 3 days of
flu-like symptoms with a temperature of 101oF
three consecutive nights. At the end of August 1994, she developed
could not ride her bicycle as long as she was used to. She did not
either a tick bite or a rash. By the beginning of September 1994, she
trouble concentrating, experienced short-term memory problems, and was
increasingly fatigued. She had bilateral knee pain without redness or
She noted a lot of "crunching" in the joints. She went to see her
primary physician. Tests for infectious mononucleosis and rheumatoid
were all negative. Because she lived in an area endemic for Lyme
spent much time outdoors, the physician performed a Lyme
disease antibody test in October 1994. The test was positive, and she
was started on oral doxycycline, 100 mg b.i.d. for 30
Her symptoms persisted and antibiotic treatment was extended for a
total of 3
months. At the end of this period, she felt better but reported that
not "normal." Her physician felt that additional treatment was
unnecessary. In March 1995, the patient complained of recurrent frontal
headaches, vertigo, shooting pains in her right ear, neck stiffness,
the paravertebral area of the upper thoracic spine, arthralgia,
the right hand, and weakness in her thigh muscles. She felt heaviness
chest and exertional dyspnea climbing a flight of stairs. She had
problems, difficulty concentrating, and irritability when referred.
Her past medical history and physical examination were unremarkable. Lyme antibody tests were repeated at North American Clinical Laboratories. The IgG ELISA titer was 1:160, and the IgM < 1: 160. The IgG test was interpreted as equivocal, and the IgM as nonreactive. The IgG western blot showed 50,41,23 Kda bands. The IgM blot showed a 31 Kda band. Both western blots were interpreted as equivocal. A PCR was done on whole blood (N.A.C.L.) and was positive. The PCR on whole blood utilized a 20 kb primer, which is a protein of the 350 kb Osp A sequence. Positive hybridization controls (HLA), DQ alpha negative controls, and inhibition controls were used in each PCR run. Amplified products were detected by both southern blotting and a nonradioisotopic DNA capture technique. Patient was restarted on oral doxycycline 100 mg b.i.d. The patient continued to have the same symptoms with exacerbations once a week while on the oral doxycycline. The PCR test on whole blood was repeated 1 month later while on doxycycline. It was again positive for Bb. After the second positive DNA-PCR test result, the patient was switched to intravenous Ceftriaxone 2 g q.d. for 4 weeks. At the end of 2 1/2 weeks, she developed an allergic rash, and the I.V. therapy was discontinued. As of this writing, she is being continued on oral Biaxin (500 mg b.i.d. [=clarithromycine]). The patient has improved significantly and is 95% better.
chronic relapsing neuroborreliosis [see comments]
Lawrence C, Lipton RB, Lowy FD, Coyle PK. Eur Neurol 1995;35(2): 113-7. PMID: 7796837
We report an unusual patient with evidence of Borrelia burgdorferi infection who experienced repeated neurologic relapses despite aggressive antibiotic therapy. Each course of therapy was associated with a Jarisch-Herxheimer-like reaction. Although the patient never had detectable free antibodies to B. burgdorferi in serum or spinal fluid, the CSF was positive on multiple occasions for complexed anti-B. burgdorferi antibodies, B. burgdorferi nucleic acids and free antigen.
Repeated Isolation of Borrelia burgdorferi from the
Cerebrospinal Fluid of Two Patients Treated for Lyme Neuroborreliosis.
Cimperman J, Strle F, Maraspin V, Lotric S, Ruzic Sabljic E, Picken RN. 1996 VII Int Conf Lb abs #D657 University of California, Berkeley, p 181.
The clinical diagnosis of neuroborreliosis (NB) remains challenging and the efficacy of antibiotic therapy in its treatment is uncertain. We present the case histories of two patients with NB who had unusual clinical presentations and failed to respond to conventional antibiotic therapy.
Patient #1 was a 20 year old woman who presented with lymphocytic meningitis. No antibodies against Borrelia burgdorferi (BB) were detectable in her serum and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF). Subsequently, 1.5 months later, BB was cultured from the CSF and the patient was treated with ceftriaxone (2g/day for 14 days). The patient was asymptomatic for 3.5 months; thereafter, she developed a right lumboischialgia. Analgesic therapy was unsuccessful. The CSF showed increased proteins (0.98 g/L), but again no antibodies against BB were detectable in serum and CSF. However, BB was once again cultured from the CSF. The patient was treated again with ceftriaxone and subsequently recovered. Currently, the patient is lost for follow-up.
Patient #2 was a 51 year old female who developed erythema migrans (EM) following a tick bite. At that time she received no antibiotic treatment. Two months later she developed multiple neurologic symptoms including headache, vertigo, nausea, left nervus trigeminus paresthesia, memory/ concentration disorders and depression, as well as myalgia, arthralgia, and ocular symptoms. Low titres of IgM antibodies against Bb were detected in the serum; serologic tests for neurotropic viruses and syphilis were negative. Routine CSF tests were normal; no anti-Bb antibodies were detectable. VEP were abnormal, while CT, MRI of the brain and EEG were all normal. Bb was cultured from the CSF 9 months after the initial presentation with EM. The patient was treated with ceftriaxone (2g/day) for 14 days. Two months after treatment, Bb was again isolated from the CSF. Four months after the initial therapy, the symptoms persisted and, in addition, monoarthritis developed. Antibiotic therapy was repeated and included ceftriaxone (2g/day) for 21 days. The patient improved approximately one month after completion of the latter therapy.
results demonstrate that:
(1) negative serology does not exclude diagnosis of NB,
(2) Bb can persist in the CSF following antibiotic treatment,
(3) standard ceftriaxone therapy (2g/day for 14 days) may not be sufficient for the treatment of NB.
of PCR assays to monitor the clearance of Borrelia burgdorferi DNA
from blood following antibiotic therapy
Manak MM, Gonzįlez-Villaseńor LI,Crush-Stanton S, Tilton RC. J Spiro Tick Diseases 1997; 4:11-20
(33%) early Lyme disease patients and 10 of 20 (50%) late-stage
patients not on
antibiotic therapy at the time of enrollment were PCR positive.
All seven PCR-positive early Lyme disease patients and 8 of the 10 PCR-positive late-stage patients became PCR negative within 2 weeks of antibiotic treatment.
Of an additional eight late-stage patients who had been on therapy for more than 2 months at the time of enrollment, three were PCR positive. All five late-stage patients who remained PCR positive while under therapy (two from the newly treated group and three from the previously treated group) became PCR negative when alternative therapy was administered.
[table 2. Two of the patients with 'Late Lyme Disease Before Therapy' were seronegative before treatment, one PCR-negative seroconverted, while one PCR-positive remained seronegative.]
report demonstrates several phenomena:
1. Despite aggressive IV and oral antimicrobial treatment, B. burgdorferi may persist in sequestered areas of the body such as bone marrow
2. The yield on PCR testing for Lyme disease may be enhanced by testing bone marrow specimens or, by extrapolation, testing leucocytes, ie, buffy coat, where the organism may reside intracellularly protected from immune defenses. The bone marrow provides a specimen resource rich in nucleated cells, which may harbor the spirochete in dormant or active form. We clearly do not advocate this invasive testing for all patients but rather those who are refractory to standard therapy and have concomitant immunologic or hematologic abnormalities.
3. There does not appear to be a clear correlation between reactive Lyme serology and PCR positivity, although one patient had a persistently positive IgG and IgM Western Blot and the other a positive ELISA test.
In conclusion, these cases reports suggest that bone marrow may be an important site for detection of B. burgdorferi DNA.
Marrow as a Source for Borrelia burgdorferi DNA.
Fein L, Tilton R. J Spiro Tick Diseases 1997; 4:58-60
51y F, lupus-like disease NSAID. Frequent infections, joint pains, headaches and fatigue. Plaquenil plus intermittent antibiotics. Steroids. ANA 1:40. Biopsy of mediastinal glands: noncaseating granulomas, atypical for sarcoidosis. Progressive improvement ... Jan 1993 influenzalike illness ass w severe arthritis and neck stiffness. Biaxin (clarithromycin) and suprax (cefixime) for presumptive seronegative Lyme disease. Initial flare … progressively worse … march 1993 i.v. claforan (cefotaxime). ANA repeatedly negative, experienced multiple JHR requiring adjustment of dose. After 2 months on i.v. antimicrobials her condition improved. She had no additional antimicrobials until March 1994 when she developed gradually recurring symptoms. ANA's negative or weak. ELISA reactive, but not confirmed by Western Blot. She was maintained on zithromax (azithromycin) and plaquenil. Immunological studies normal except for IgG and lambda monoclonal gammopathy. In september bone marrow biopsy was performed. PCR for B. burgdorferi was reactive. IM bicillin 1.2 mu and oral zithromax 250mg x2. The patient was maintained on the above regimen until clinical remission with progressive improvement of all her symptoms.
59y F seen April 1994 after being treated by another physician for Lyme disease. Multiple influenza-like illnesses in 1992 through 1993 and was treated with short courses of oral antibiotics. She went to Spain in 1993. This trip was followed by the onset of severe pain and weakness. ….IgM Western Blot was reactive. …. IV Claforan (cefotaxime) for 8 weeks. She initially felt better but relapsed. Intravenous ampicillin was administered for 1 month followed by claforan 9g/d for 2 weeks which was reduced to 6g/d. By May 1994, there was lack of response … IV Vancomycin. The patient responded well, but relapsed when vancomycin was discontimued…. Restarted Vancomycin June 1994 and responded well. Therapy was continued through July followed by pulse vancomycin and bicillin LA. By august 1994 she was very symptomatic with fevers and arthritis. IV vancomycin was stopped and plaquenil started in addition to IM bicillin. The patient was noted to have hypogammaglobulinaemia and anemia and was treated with IV gammaglobulin and transfusions. The patient did well until October 1994 when both symptoms and anemia recurred. The consulting hematologist performed a bone marrow biopsy that was unremarkable except for a positive PCR (B. burgdorferi). By November 1994 she had recurrent fevers and arthitis. Her anemia is stable on Epogen (epoetin alpha) and her strength is improving on Plaquenil. She has had two gammaglobulin transfusions for recurrent hypogammaglobulinaemia. Throughout this time, both her IgG and IgM Western Blot have remained consistently positive. The patient is now reporting she is feeling better.
Disease and the clinical Spectrum of Antibiotics responsive Chronic
Liegner KB, Duray P, Agricola M, Rosenkilde C, Yannuzzi LA, Ziska M, Tilton RC, Hulinska D, Hubbard J, Fallon BA. J Spiro Tick Diseases 1997;4:61-73.
Intensive study of four patients with chronic meningoencephalomyelitis believed due to Lyme disease revealed seronegativity and/or variable seroreactivity and chronic persistent infection as common threads. Evaluation of these complex cases required determined study over time using all known methods (i.e., culture isolation, histologic, immunohistochemical, electron micrographic, direct antigen detection as well as standard serologic methods) on tissues as well as serial study of blood, cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) and urine.
intravenous antibiotic therapy conferred clinical benefit in each case
withholding of treatment resulted in clinical deterioration.
These 4 cases demonstrate:
1. Long term seronegativity for borrelia despite longterm symptomatology consistent with borreliosis
2. Repeatedly antibiotic responsive while relapses occurred when treatment was paused or decreased
3. Difficulty in discriminating chronic active Lyme borreliosis from MS (case 4) and lupus (case 1).
4. Severe worsening whenever steroid treatment is used in chronic active Lyme borreliosis.
5. Severe debilitating illness from borreliosis and death following vascular hemorrhage
A 39-year-old woman with a two-year history of progressing spastic quadraparesis, cranial nerve palsies, and persistent unexplained CSF pleocytosis was evaluated beginning in 1989. She had been diagnosed with idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura (ITP) in 1975 and underwent splenectomy in 1976. She had lived in northern Westchester county, New York and northern California but gave no history of tick attachments or of erythema migrans. No diagnosis was established after a year of observation and testing, and serologic studies for Lyme disease in serum and CSF were repeatedly negative. CSF examination in 1990 showed lymphocytic pleocytosis, elevated IgG, and absence of oligoclonal bands or myelin basic protein. Anticardiolipin and antinuclear antibodies were present and Raji cell assay and C1Q immune complexes were elevated. HIV and HTLV-1 antibodies were negative.
An empiric trial of intravenous antibiotic treatment with cefotaxime (CFOTX) for 21 days in April 1990 resulted in no clinical improvement and no change in CSF pleocytosis. Thereafter she was treated with 4 months of minocycline with no clinical benefit. The patient remained wheelchair-bound.
B. burgdorferi grew from CSF in December 1991 at which time the patient first became seropositive despite at least 4 years of clinical illness. She was treated with CFOTX (4 g IV Q 8 hrs once weekly) with complete resolution of pleocytosis after 13 weeks and constitutional symptoms improved. Despite continuation of once weekly IV therapy for 10 months, there was gradual neurologic deterioration. Intravenous antibiotics were discontinued December 1992.
Methylprednisolone sodium succinate was given intravenously, 1 g daily for 5 days, followed by prednisone over a six-week period for the possibility of systemic lupus erythematosus. Pleural effusions developed within one week of starting steroids along with severe encephalopathy and debilitation. She could not remember conversations held minutes earlier and was unable to hold a cup, roll over in bed, or transfer from bed to wheelchair. Computed axial tomography of the chest revealed pleuropericardial effusions (Fig 1). A pleuropericardial window was created for diagnostic and therapeutic purposes. Fibrinous pericarditis was present with infiltration of plasma cells and macrophages and spirochete-compatible structures were seen with modified Steiner silver and phycoerythrin stains, as well as a touch preparation (Figs 2-5). Intravenous CFOTX 6 g daily was administered for the next 3fi months with dramatic improvement of her encephalopathy. The pleuropericardial effusions improved (Fig 6). The patient was able to walk 500 feet with a rolling walker and was able to go home. A further 3 months of daily CFOTX was administered but the patient's health insurer refused authorization for any subsequent intravenous antibiotic therapy. The patient became increasingly encephalopathic over the next 6 months. Daily intravenous CFOTX was reinstituted in June 1994 and mental status improved as confirmed by serial neuropsychological testing before and after 4 months of treatment. Several specimens of plasma and urine between February and July of 1995 were found to be PCR positive for B. burdorferi-specific DNA. From July 1995 through April 1996 the patient was treated with intramuscular benzathine penicillin. On this treatment she felt poorly, encephalopathy worsened, and she lost the ability to ambulate. Plasma PCR for B. burdorferi-specific DNA was again positive February 1996. CSF analysis March 1996 showed 14 lymphocytes/mm3, elevated protein (57 mg %) and slight elevation of IgG. Oligoclonal bands were present in both CSF and serum. Myelin basic protein was absent. CSF Lyme PCR and OspA antigen were negative as were Lyme-specific immune complexes in serum and CSF. Authorization for additional intravenous antibiotic therapy was refused by the insurer. Encephalopathy and debilitation worsened (Table I).
In the fall of 1985 a 61-year-old outdoorsman residing in the Catskill region of New York State developed a large round rash on one thigh. A physician was consulted but no treatment was given. The following winter unrelenting headache, low grade fever, paresthesias and truncal instability developed. Lumbar puncture demonstrated lymphocytic pleocytosis. Lyme ELISA was negative. Dysphasia and a progressive stroke syndrome developed. A diagnosis of "vasculitis" was given and the patient was treated with steroids and cyclophosphamide for a number of months with progressive deterioration to a level of functioning slightly above a persistent vegetative state. Lyme ELISA was positive in 1988. Treatment with intramuscular ceftriaxone (CFTRX) for 14 days resulted in slight improvement. In 1992, computed axial tomography of the brain showed massive hydrocephalus (Fig 7). Electroencephalogram revealed status epilepticus and phenobarbital was prescribed. Lyme serology was negative in one laboratory, yet positive in another. Western blot was nondiagnostic, showing only a 41 kiloDalton band. CSF examination revealed the presence of oligoclonal bands without myelin basic protein and very elevated CSF IgG. Serum showed elevated C1Q immune complexes. OspA antigen capture assay in CSF was strongly positive. The patient was given daily intravenous CFTRX for one month, then weekly CFOTX (4 g IV Q 8 hr x 3 doses) for one year, with modest improvement in his neurologic status. The patient succumbed to his disease July 1993. Autopsy revealed severe hydrocephalus (Figs 8,9) and florid meningoencephalomyelitis and ependymitis (Figs 10-13). The CSF was positive for OspA antigen and Lyme-specific immune complexes. Spirochetes were not visualized on histopathologic and immunohistochemical study by light microscopy but borrelia-compatible structures were visualized in formalin-fixed tissues studied by electron microscopy (Figs 14-16) and brain tissue and dura mater were PCR positive for detection of B. burgdorferi-specific oligonucleotides (Figs 17A,B) (Table II).
About case 3 & 4 from discussion (for full story see above link):
Case 3 had a clear clinical history indicating Lyme disease. Despite intensive study laboratory corroboration for the diagnosis could not be obtained for some 13 years. A prior six-week course of intravenous CFTRX did not prevent the development of meningoencephalomyelitis. An eight-month course of intravenous CFOTX was required to resolve disturbed CSF parameters. Lyme-specific immune complexes were demonstrable in the final three of five cerebrospinal fluid examinations and key Lyme disease-compatible bands finally developed on Western blot in serum thereafter. She has been seronegative by ELISA throughout, calling into serious question the validity of using this assay alone as a screening test.
Case 4 demonstrates how closely neuroborreliosis can mimic multiple sclerosis. Given now that seronegativity occurs in Lyme disease, distinguishing the two disorders may be a daunting task. The patient showed resolution of markers thought to be pathognomonic for multiple sclerosis in CSF along with clinical improvement following intensive intravenous antibiotic treatment. Relapse of abnormal CSF findings and of neurologic signs occurred with suspension of intensive treatment. Resolution again followed a second course of intravenous therapy. This case suggests that neuroborreliosis may be misdiagnosed as multiple sclerosis. [18,19]
proposal for the reliable culture of Borrelia burgdorferi from
patients with chronic Lyme disease, even from those previously
Phillips SE, Mattman LH, Hulinska D, Moayad H. Infection 1998 Nov-Dec;26(6):364-7. PMID: 9861561
culture of Borrelia burgdorferi from patients with chronic Lyme disease
been an extraordinarily rare event, clarification of the nature of the
and proving its etiology as infectious have been difficult. A method
reliably and reproducibly culturing B. burgdorferi from the blood of
with chronic Lyme disease was therefore sought by making a controlled
blood culture trial studying 47 patients
with chronic Lyme disease. All had relapsed after long-term oral and
23 patients with other chronic illness
formed the control group. Positive
cultures were confirmed by fluorescent antibody immuno-electron
using monoclonal antibody directed against Osp A, and Osp A PCR.
43/47 patients (91%) cultured positive. 23/23 controls (100%) cultured negative. Although persistent infection has been, to date, strongly suggested in chronic Lyme disease by positive PCR and antigen capture, there are major problems with these tests. This new method for culturing B. burgdorferi from patients with chronic Lyme disease certainly defines the nature of the illness and establishes that it is of chronic infectious etiology. This discovery should help to reestablish the gold standard in laboratory diagnosis of Lyme disease.
regarding this paper:
Unanswered question 'Why does the culture medium contain Detroit tap water, instead of distilled water as usual?' - Does tap water perhaps contain some minerals (Ca?, Mg?) that Bb may need for its growth outside hosts?
TOP European American Animal
Animal studiesPathogenesis of neuroborreliosis--lessons from a monkey model.
diagnosis of human LNB can be difficult, because its major clinical
manifestations--meningitis, facial palsy, radiculitis, and
non-specific and the characteristic skin lesion is usually absent at
of neurological involvement. Thus, CSF assays are often used in
Culture of CSF is rarely performed because it has a low yield and
culture medium. PCR of the CSF identified spirochetal DNA in clinical
with greater sensitivity, but it suffers from a number of
Measurement of specific antibody in the CSF also has its limitations.
of available assays for LNB has not been studied carefully in a
investigation. The recent development of the nonhumane primate (NHP)
LNB allows us to address this need in a faithful model of human LNB. We
compared PCR and culture in their ability to detect spirochetal
presence in the
CSF and brain tissue of infected NHPs, and related these measures of
to the development of anti-B. burgdorferi antibody. We
also tested a bioassay, the mouse infectivity test (MIT), in this
assays (PCR, culture, MIT, and CSF
Ab) at least one assay for spirochetal presence in CSFs from NHPs was
in 87% of CSFs tested during early infection in the CNS. Detection of
spirochetal presence by PCR, MIT, and culture in the CSF was inversely
related to the concomitant presence of anti-B. burgdorferi antibody
intrathecally. The performance of any particular test
was associated with the strength of the host immune response. In
early CNS infection, when anti-B. burgdorferi
antibody had not yet appeared, or in immunocompromised
hosts, the MIT compared favorably to culture and PCR in
antibody in the CSF was the most useful assay in immunocompetent NHPs.
is the first study demonstrating that a bioassay using inoculation
mice, the mouse infectivity test (MIT), has potential as a useful
the diagnosis of LNB. The MIT for LNB was modeled after the rabbit
test or RIT, which is considered the "gold standard" for the
diagnosis of the related CNS infection, neurosyphilis, and felt to be
sensitive and specific. The presence
burgdorferi antibody in
the CSF is the most
used assay for Lyme neuroborreliosis. In
the immunocompetent NHPs in our study it was a very successful assay
detection of CNS invasion. However, it is frequently false-negative,
early in the course of the infection, or if there is transient
suppression of the
response in the human
in instances of co-infection, i.e. simultaneous transmission via the
another pathogen other than B. burgdorferi. Thus,
immunosuppression as accomplished in our NHPs with corticosteroids was
to mimic conditions in the human host which allow B. burgdorferi in the
state to gain a firm foothold in the central nervous system in the
10-15% of B.
burgdorferi-infected patients who develop clinically symptomatic
study is the
compare utility of available diagnostic techniques in LNB in which
proved presence of infection in the CNS. None of the assays was ideal
conditions, and the utility of the assay was associated with the host
status. The differences in the responses of immunocompromised
immunocompetent NHPs in this study were striking.
immunocompetent NHPs the window of opportunity for CNS invasion prior
development of CSF antibody was brief, and the chance of detection of
spirochete low by any of the three techniques used (i.e. culture, PCR,
in this group, measurement of CSF antibody was generally diagnostic. In
production was delayed, and this helpful diagnostic assay was
diagnosis required more labor-intensive assays such as PCR, culture,
during weeks 3.5 to 9.5 after infection. It
the experiment been allowed to proceed
longer in the
immunosuppressed NHPs, antibody would have eventually been produced
The clinical relevance of the data on comparison of diagnostic assays is clear. The appearance of anti-B. burgdorferi antibody in CSF may be delayed especially when there is interference with the anti-B. burgdorferi immune response. In these circumstances, or for a short time early in CNS invasion in immunocompetent individuals, the measurement of anti-B. burgdorferi antibody in CSF may be negative; under these circumstances the likelyhood of detecting spirochete by PCR, culture, or MIT is at its highest. Conversely, detecting spirochetal presence by clture, PCR, or MIT will be least likely to be successful when anti-B. burgdorferi antibody is present.
(the last part of abstract was truncated in Medline but added here).
of Borrelia burgdorferi in experimentally infected dogs
after antibiotic treatment.
Straubinger RK, Summers BA, Chang YF, Appel MJ. J Clin Microbiol 1997 Jan; 35(1): 111-6 PMID: 8968890 PDF
In specific-pathogen-free dogs experimentally infected with Borrelia burgdorferi by tick exposure, treatment with high doses of amoxicillin or doxycycline for 30 days diminished but failed to eliminate persistent infection. Although joint disease was prevented or cured in five of five amoxicillin- and five of six doxycycline-treated dogs, skin punch biopsies and multiple tissues from necropsy samples remained PCR positive and B. burgdorferi was isolated from one amoxicillin- and two doxycycline-treated dogs following antibiotic treatment. In contrast, B. burgdorferi was isolated from six of six untreated infected control dogs and joint lesions were found in four of these six dogs. Serum antibody levels to B. burgdorferi in all dogs declined after antibiotic treatment. Negative antibody levels were reached in four of six doxycycline- and four of six amoxicillin-treated dogs. However, in dogs that were kept in isolation for 6 months after antibiotic treatment was discontinued, antibody levels began to rise again, presumably in response to proliferation of the surviving pool of spirochetes. Antibody levels in untreated infected control dogs remained high.
lessons from the canine model of Lyme disease: Migration of Borrelia
burgdorferi in tissues and persistence after antibiotic treatment
Straubinger RK, Straubinger AF, Jacobson RH, Chang YF, Summers BA, Erb HM, Appel MJG. J Spiro Tick Diseases 1997; 4:24-31.
...... Tissues closest to the infection site harbored spirochetes more frequently than did more distant tissues. Of all tested tissues taken from the front quadrant (synovium, lymph node, fascia, and muscle) that contained the site of inoculation, 75% were culture positive. In the opposite front quarter, 60% of the tissues were positive for B. burgdorferi, tissues from the hind quarters showed 26% and 16% culture positivity when they originated from the side of exposure or from the opposite side, respectively. The development of severe arthritis with clinically evi-dent lameness was associated with the side of infection. Of 70 tick-infected and lame dogs, 80% developed the first episode of acute arthritis in joints closest to the tick bites after a median incubation of 68 days. Ten percent of the dogs showed clinically evident lameness in the limb of the opposite front quadrant after 121 days, 8.6% in the ipsilateral hind quadrant after 103 days, and 1.4% in the opposite hind quadrant after 123 days posttick exposure. We have shown that in untreated dogs, B. burgdorferi can persist in connective tissue for at least a year and perhaps for life. In two studies, antibiotic treatment with amoxicillin or doxycycline for 30 days failed to eliminate persistent infection in 11 dogs. Immediately after treatment, borreliae could not be demonstrated, antibody levels declined, and joint lesions were prevented or cured. Live spirochetes, however, persisted in the tissue of at least three dogs as B. burgdorferi DNA was detected in all 11 treated dogs for up to 6 months after treatment, at which time antibody levels again began to rise. Additional therapeutic studies using intravenously administered ceftriaxone or oral azithromycin are underway in an attempt to identify a successful treatment regime.
manifestations, pathogenesis, and effect of
antibiotic treatment on Lyme borreliosis in dogs.
Straubinger RK, Straubinger AF, Summers BA, Jacobson RH, Erb HN. Wien Klin Wochenschr 1998 Dec 23;110(24):874-81 PMID: 10048169
Borrelia burgdorferi, the causative agent of Lyme disease, infects
animals. In humans, the disease primarily affects the skin, large
the nervous system days to months after infection. Data generated with
appropriate animal model help to understand the fundamental mechanisms
of the disease.
1) More clearly define the clinical manifestation and pathogenetic mechanisms of Lyme disease in dogs;
2) evaluate the effect of antibiotics in dogs infected with B. burgdorferi;
3) describe the effects of corticosteroids on dogs persistently infected with B. burgdorferi.
DESIGN: Specific-pathogen-free beagles were infected with B. burgdorferi using ticks collected in an endemic Lyme disease area. Clinical signs were recorded daily. Antibody titers were measured by ELISA at two-week intervals. B. burgdorferi organisms were detected in tissues by culture and PCR. Synovial fluids were evaluated microscopically and with a chemotaxis cell migration assay. Histological sections were examined for pathological lesions. Specific cytokine up-regulation in tissues was detected by RT-PCR.
In three separate experiments, B. burgdorferi-infected dogs received antibiotic treatment (amoxicillin; azithromycin; ceftriaxone; doxycycline) for 30 consecutive days. Two subclinical persistently infected dogs received oral prednisone for 14 consecutive days starting at day 420 post-infection.
RESULTS: Dogs developed acute arthritis in the joints closest to the tick bites after a median incubation period of 68 days. Synovial membranes of lame and non-lame dogs produced the chemokine IL-8 in response to B. burgdorferi. Antibiotic treatment prevented or resolved episodes of acute arthritis, but failed to eliminate the bacterium from infected dogs. Corticosteroid treatment reactivated Lyme disease in persistently infected dogs, which had not received antibiotics previously.
CONCLUSIONS: B. burgdorferi disseminates through tissue by migration following tick inoculation, produces episodes of acute arthritis, and establishes persistent infection. The spirochete survives antibiotic treatment and disease can be reactivated in immunosuppressed animals.
The persistence of symptoms
in Lyme disease patients following antibiotic therapy, and their
causes, continue to be a matter of intense controversy. The studies
presented here explore antibiotic efficacy using nonhuman primates. Rhesus macaques were infected
with B. burgdorferi and a portion received aggressive antibiotic
Multiple methods were utilized for detection of residual organisms, including the feeding of lab-reared ticks on monkeys (xenodiagnosis), culture, immunofluorescence and PCR.
Antibody responses to the B. burgdorferi-specific C6 diagnostic peptide were measured longitudinally and declined in all treated animals.
B. burgdorferi antigen, DNA and RNA were detected in the tissues of treated animals.
Finally, small numbers of intact spirochetes were recovered by xenodiagnosis from treated monkeys.
These results demonstrate that B. burgdorferi can withstand antibiotic treatment, administered post-dissemination, in a primate host. Though B. burgdorferi is not known to possess resistance mechanisms and is susceptible to the standard antibiotics (doxycycline, ceftriaxone) in vitro, it appears to become tolerant post-dissemination in the primate host.
This finding raises important questions about the pathogenicity of antibiotic-tolerant persisters and whether or not they can contribute to symptoms post-treatment.
TOP European American Animal